Amy’s Closet

Store Information

Phone: +1 812-565-2197

Store Hours

• Monday: Closed
• Tuesday: Closed
• Wednesday: 11AM-7PM
• Thursday: 11AM-7PM
• Friday: 11AM-7PM
• Saturday: 11AM-7PM
• Sunday: 11AM-5PM

What They Sell

Amy's Closet offers an extensive selection of pre-loved items spanning clothing for all ages, accessories, housewares, and decorative pieces. Fashion enthusiasts will appreciate the range of women's, men's, and children's apparel, from everyday basics to occasional designer finds. The home goods section features everything from practical kitchen essentials to unique decorative accents that add character to any space. What sets Amy's Closet apart is their dedication to quality—each item undergoes inspection before hitting the sales floor, ensuring shoppers find gently used treasures in excellent condition.

The Neighborhood

Located on 25th Street in Columbus, Indiana, Amy's Closet sits in a vibrant retail corridor that's easily accessible from all parts of the city. The store is conveniently positioned near the Columbus Center shopping plaza and just minutes from downtown Columbus' architectural landmarks. This eastside neighborhood combines residential charm with practical amenities, making it an ideal spot for locals to incorporate thrift shopping into their regular errands.

Parking

Amy's Closet offers convenient free parking in the shared lot directly in front of the store at 3928 25th St. This spacious lot typically has ample spots available, even during weekend peak hours. For those combining shopping trips, the lot connects to neighboring businesses, making it easy to visit multiple stops in one convenient visit. Street parking is also available along 25th Street for quick pop-in visits.

Shopping Tips

• Sign up for Amy's Closet email list at checkout to receive alerts about special sales events and discount days exclusive to subscribers.
• Visit on Wednesdays when new inventory typically hits the floor for the best selection of fresh items.
• Check the color-coded tag system—each week features different colored tags offering additional discounts beyond the marked prices.
• Bring your own reusable shopping bags to make carrying your treasures home easier while supporting the store's eco-friendly mission.
• Don't hesitate to ask staff about upcoming inventory—they're often happy to let you know when seasonal items will be featured.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Amy’s Closet:

• MINE, YOURS AND THEIRS — Columbus, IN
• Grizzlee Pretty thrift shop & collectibles & Toy’s — Columbus, IN
• Goodwill Store — Columbus, IN
• Sans Souci Inc — Columbus, IN
• Psi iota xi sorority thrift shop — Columbus, IN
• Goodwill Store — Columbus, IN
• The Imaginary Shop — Edinburgh, IN
• Amazing Grace Thrift Shop — Edinburgh, IN

Find More Thrift Stores in Columbus, IN

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Columbus, IN.

• All Thrift Stores in Columbus, IN
• All Thrift Stores in IN
• Search All Thrift Stores Nationwide