Lucky Penny Thrift

Lucky Penny Thrift on East 31st Street is one of Tulsa's hidden gems for secondhand shoppers who know that the best finds don't always come with a big price tag. Tucked into the heart of midtown Tulsa, OK, this thrift store carries the kind of unpretentious, roll-up-your-sleeves shopping energy that seasoned thrifters genuinely love. Whether you're hunting for vintage furniture, everyday household essentials, or a quirky piece of decor, Lucky Penny Thrift delivers the thrill of the unexpected. The name says it all — every visit feels like stumbling across a lucky find. Tulsa locals who frequent the East 31st corridor have embraced Lucky Penny Thrift as a go-to stop for affordable secondhand goods without the hassle of big-box resale chains. It's the kind of place where patience and curiosity are rewarded.

Store Information

4630 E 31st St, Tulsa, OK 74135

Store Hours

Typical thrift store hours — please call ahead to confirm:

  • Monday–Saturday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
  • Sunday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM

What They Sell

Lucky Penny Thrift stocks the kind of rotating, ever-changing inventory that keeps Tulsa secondhand shoppers coming back week after week. Expect to find a broad mix of secondhand goods including clothing for men, women, and children, housewares, kitchenware, books, small furniture, décor, and general merchandise. Because thrift store inventory is donation-driven, no two visits are the same — one trip might turn up a vintage lamp, the next a barely-used kitchen appliance or a great rack of gently worn clothing. That unpredictability is exactly the appeal.

The Neighborhood

Lucky Penny Thrift sits along East 31st Street in midtown Tulsa, OK, a well-traveled commercial corridor that connects several established neighborhoods. The area is easily accessible from both the 51st Street Peoria district and the broader Midtown Tulsa community. With a mix of longtime locals and younger Tulsans discovering the value of secondhand shopping, the East 31st neighborhood brings a practical, unpretentious energy that fits perfectly with thrift store culture.

Parking

Lucky Penny Thrift is located at 4630 E 31st Street, a commercial stretch in midtown Tulsa that typically features off-street parking directly in front of or adjacent to the storefront. Most businesses along this corridor offer surface lot or shared plaza parking, making a quick thrift run convenient without the stress of hunting for a spot.

Shopping Tips

  • Here are a few insider tips for making the most of your visit to Lucky Penny Thrift in Tulsa, OK:
  • Visit early in the week — Monday and Tuesday are often when freshly donated items hit the floor after weekend drop-offs, giving you first pick of new arrivals.
  • Bring cash and small bills — some smaller Tulsa thrift stores prefer or exclusively accept cash, and having exact change keeps the checkout line moving.
  • Check every section, even ones outside your usual interest — thrift shoppers who wander beyond their comfort zone consistently find the most surprising and valuable pieces.
  • Inspect items carefully before purchasing — secondhand goods are sold as-is, so take an extra minute to check zippers, seams, cords, and surfaces before you commit.
  • Come back often — inventory at Lucky Penny Thrift changes constantly, and the shoppers who visit regularly are the ones who walk away with the best deals.

Before You Go

Lucky Penny Thrift's hours have not been publicly listed at this time, so it's worth calling ahead or checking their storefront directly before making a trip. As with many Tulsa thrift stores, weekday mornings tend to offer the freshest restocked inventory with fewer competing shoppers. Visiting earlier in the week after a weekend of donations is often a smart strategy for finding the best secondhand goods before the shelves get picked over.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Lucky Penny Thrift:

Find More Thrift Stores in Tulsa, OK

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Tulsa, OK.