Middle Earth Treasures

Middle Earth Treasures on East 31st Street is one of Tulsa's most intriguing secondhand destinations, offering shoppers a curated hunting ground for pre-loved items with genuine character. Tucked into the heart of east Tulsa, OK, this shop carries the kind of personality that big-box thrift chains simply can't replicate — the kind where a single visit might turn up a vintage lamp, a collectible figurine, or a barely-worn jacket at a price that feels almost too good to be true. With 22 reviews already building a local reputation, Middle Earth Treasures has earned its place among Tulsa thrift shoppers who appreciate a more intimate, thoughtfully stocked store. The name itself sets the tone — expect the unexpected, and come ready to dig. Whether you're a seasoned thrifter or just starting your secondhand journey, the 6137 E 31st St location makes it easy to stop in and see what treasures have surfaced since your last visit.

Store Information

6137 E 31st St, Tulsa, OK 74135

Phone: +1 918-240-9650

4.7★ average across 27 reviews on Google

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: 10AM-5:30PM
  • Wednesday: 10AM-5:30PM
  • Thursday: 10AM-5:30PM
  • Friday: 10AM-5:30PM
  • Saturday: 10AM-4PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

Middle Earth Treasures stocks a rotating mix of secondhand goods that keeps regulars coming back week after week. Shoppers can expect to find household items, clothing, accessories, décor, books, and the kind of miscellaneous curiosities that make thrift shopping genuinely exciting. Because inventory turns over organically through donations and acquisitions, no two visits look exactly alike. The store leans into its name — there's a sense that something unusual or collectible might be waiting on any given shelf. From functional everyday finds to the occasional one-of-a-kind piece, Middle Earth Treasures rewards shoppers who take their time and browse with an open mind.

The Neighborhood

Middle Earth Treasures sits along East 31st Street, a well-traveled Tulsa corridor that connects midtown to east Tulsa neighborhoods. The area is a practical and familiar stretch for locals, close to everyday shopping and easy to reach from several surrounding communities including South Tulsa and the Brookside area. It's the kind of neighborhood where an independent thrift shop feels right at home.

Parking

Middle Earth Treasures is located along East 31st Street, a commercial strip where off-street parking is typically available in a shared lot adjacent to or near the storefront. Street parking along 31st may also be an option depending on the time of day. Arriving during off-peak hours on weekdays generally means the easiest parking access.

Shopping Tips

  • Get the most out of your visit to Middle Earth Treasures with these insider tips:
  • **Visit early in the week** — Tuesday and Wednesday are prime days to catch freshly added inventory before the weekend crowd picks through it.
  • **Come with an open list** — Middle Earth Treasures rewards flexible shoppers. Have a general sense of what you need, but stay open to surprises you didn't know you were looking for.
  • **Check every section** — Items at smaller thrift stores like this one don't always end up in obvious categories, so a slow browse through every aisle often uncovers the best finds.
  • **On Saturdays, arrive close to 10AM** — With the store closing at 4PM on weekends, an early Saturday arrival gives you the best shot at a full, unhurried shopping experience.
  • **Follow up regularly** — Because secondhand inventory is always changing, stopping in every week or two is the surest way to catch something special before it's gone.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Middle Earth Treasures:

Find More Thrift Stores in Tulsa, OK

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Tulsa, OK.