New Reflections

New Reflections in Hayward, WI is one of those hidden gem thrift stores that locals keep coming back to for its ever-changing inventory and genuine community atmosphere. Tucked along County Road B, this secondhand shop offers a refreshing alternative to big-box retail, giving shoppers the thrill of the hunt in a relaxed, welcoming environment. Whether you're a seasoned thrifter or just curious about what treasures might be waiting, New Reflections delivers that satisfying feeling of finding something special at an unbeatable price. The store reflects the character of the Hayward area itself — unpretentious, practical, and full of surprises. Neighbors and visitors alike appreciate the value-driven shopping experience, where quality secondhand goods get a second chance at a loving home.

Store Information

15495 Co Rd B, Hayward, WI 54843

5★ average across 5 reviews on Google

Store Hours

Typical thrift store hours — please call ahead to confirm:

  • Monday–Saturday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
  • Sunday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM

What They Sell

Shoppers at New Reflections can expect a rotating selection of secondhand goods spanning clothing, housewares, furniture, books, and everyday essentials. Like the best thrift stores in northern Wisconsin, the inventory shifts regularly, meaning each visit has the potential to turn up something entirely new. From gently used kitchenware and home décor to clothing for all ages and sizes, the store caters to budget-conscious shoppers and curious bargain hunters alike. Keep an eye out for vintage finds and practical household staples that represent genuine value.

The Neighborhood

New Reflections sits along County Road B in Hayward, WI, a tight-knit northwoods community known for its stunning lakes, outdoor recreation, and friendly small-town spirit. The Hayward area draws both year-round residents and seasonal visitors exploring the Chequamegon National Forest region, making this a convenient stop whether you're a local running errands or a visitor looking to score a great deal.

Parking

New Reflections is located along County Road B, a county road setting that typically offers convenient off-street or on-site parking without the congestion of downtown shopping areas. Shoppers in Hayward, WI will generally find it easy to pull in and park close to the entrance, making it practical for loading up larger thrift finds.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit regularly — thrift store inventory at New Reflections turns over frequently, so a trip that yields little one week might produce great finds the next.
  • Bring cash as a backup, since some smaller independent thrift shops in Hayward, WI may have limited card processing options.
  • Arrive early in the week when new donations are most likely to have been sorted and put out on the floor.
  • Keep an open mind about sizing and categories — some of the best thrift scores come from browsing sections you wouldn't normally check.
  • Inspect items carefully before purchasing, and don't hesitate to ask staff about any specific items or categories you're searching for, as they often know what's in the back.

Before You Go

New Reflections has not publicly listed its hours at this time, so it's a good idea to call ahead or stop by to confirm current operating times before making a special trip. Like many independent thrift stores in Hayward, WI, hours may vary seasonally — particularly in a northwoods community that sees fluctuating traffic between summer and winter months. Visiting earlier in the week often means fresher restocked inventory at stores like this.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near New Reflections:

Find More Thrift Stores in Hayward, WI

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Hayward, WI.