Thrift Shop and More

Temporarily closed — Thrift Shop and More is not currently open. Check back soon or call ahead before visiting.

Thrift Shop and More is a beloved secondhand destination tucked along Main Street in Hayward, WI — a welcoming spot where budget-conscious shoppers and treasure hunters alike come to browse an ever-rotating mix of quality goods. Whether you're a full-time Hayward resident, a cabin owner stocking a vacation property up north, or just passing through the Northwoods, this store delivers that satisfying thrift experience where you never quite know what you'll uncover. The inventory turns over regularly, which keeps regulars coming back week after week. Hayward's tight-knit community has embraced Thrift Shop and More as more than just a place to save money — it's a spot where secondhand finds genuine second lives, and where shoppers can feel good about both their wallets and their environmental footprint.

Store Information

10578 Main St, Hayward, WI 54843

Store Hours

Typical thrift store hours — please call ahead to confirm:

  • Monday–Saturday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
  • Sunday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM

What They Sell

True to its name, Thrift Shop and More goes beyond the basics. Shoppers at this Hayward, WI secondhand store can expect a broad mix of gently used clothing for men, women, and children, along with household goods, kitchenware, décor, furniture, books, and the kind of random curiosities that make thrifting genuinely fun. Given the Northwoods setting, it's also worth keeping an eye out for outdoor gear, cabin-ready furnishings, and sporting goods that cycle through the inventory — practical finds for life in Wisconsin's lake country.

The Neighborhood

Located on Main Street in the heart of Hayward, WI, Thrift Shop and More sits in a town best known as the home of the Fresh Water Fishing Hall of Fame and gateway to the Chequamegon-Nicolet National Forest. The area draws a mix of year-round locals and seasonal visitors, making the shopping scene surprisingly vibrant. The Main Street corridor is easy to navigate with convenient access from Highway 63.

Parking

Thrift Shop and More sits along Main Street in downtown Hayward, WI, where street parking is typically the most straightforward option. Main Street generally offers parallel parking spots directly in front of and near local businesses. Availability is usually good outside of peak summer weekends, when Hayward sees higher visitor traffic.

Shopping Tips

  • Getting the most out of your visit to Thrift Shop and More in Hayward, WI is all about strategy and timing. Here are a few insider tips to keep in mind:
  • Visit early in the week when freshly donated items are most likely to have just been sorted and put out — Monday and Tuesday mornings are often prime time at independently run thrift stores.
  • Come with an open mind and no firm shopping list. The magic of a store like Thrift Shop and More is in the unexpected find, so give yourself time to browse every section rather than heading straight for one category.
  • If you're furnishing a Northwoods cabin or lake house, this is an ideal stop — practical, durable household items and furniture turn up regularly and are priced to move.
  • Check items thoroughly before purchasing, and don't hesitate to dig through full bins or lower shelves — the best finds are often underneath the surface.
  • Follow up your visit with a second trip a week or two later. Inventory changes quickly, and what wasn't there on your last visit might be waiting for you on your next one.

Before You Go

Current hours for Thrift Shop and More on Main Street in Hayward, WI have not been confirmed in our directory, so we strongly recommend calling ahead or checking the store's door signage before making a trip. Like many independent thrift stores, hours may vary seasonally — particularly in a tourist-driven town like Hayward, where summer months often bring extended hours and heavier foot traffic than the quieter winter season.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Thrift Shop and More:

Find More Thrift Stores in Hayward, WI

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Hayward, WI.