Kelleys Island Parsonage Resale Shop

Kelleys Island Parsonage Resale Shop offers a unique thrift shopping experience on one of Lake Erie's most charming islands. Located at 224 Division St in Kelleys Island, Ohio, this community-focused resale shop operates with the warmth and character you'd expect from an island establishment. The parsonage setting adds historical charm to your shopping adventure, making each visit feel like a treasure hunt through a piece of local history. Island visitors and year-round residents alike appreciate the shop's commitment to affordable prices and its role in supporting the tight-knit Kelleys Island community. Whether you're a tourist looking for a unique souvenir or a local seeking quality secondhand finds, this resale shop provides an authentic island shopping experience that's hard to find anywhere else in Ohio.

Store Information

224 Division St, Kelleys Island, OH 43438

Phone: +1 419-746-2399

Store Hours

  • Monday: 12-4PM
  • Tuesday: 12-4PM
  • Wednesday: 12-4PM
  • Thursday: 12-4PM
  • Friday: 12-4PM
  • Saturday: 12-4PM
  • Sunday: 12-4PM

What They Sell

While specific inventory varies with donations from island residents and visitors, thrift shoppers at Kelleys Island Parsonage Resale Shop can typically discover a rotating selection of gently used clothing, household items, books, and seasonal treasures. Given the island's tourist culture and summer home community, you'll often find nautical-themed décor, beach essentials, and cottage-style furnishings alongside everyday practical items. The shop reflects the unique character of island life, offering both functional goods for locals and quirky finds that capture the spirit of Lake Erie living.

The Neighborhood

Kelleys Island, Ohio is a peaceful Lake Erie island destination known for its natural beauty, glacial grooves, and small-town charm. Division Street sits in the heart of the island's compact downtown area, within easy walking or biking distance of the ferry dock, local restaurants, and historic sites. The island's relaxed atmosphere and friendly community make it a perfect spot for leisurely browsing, and the Parsonage Resale Shop fits seamlessly into the island's welcoming, unhurried pace of life.

Parking

Parking on Kelleys Island is generally relaxed and accessible, with street parking available near Division Street and throughout the small downtown area. Many visitors explore the island by golf cart or bicycle, which can be parked easily near the shop. If you're driving, you'll find the island's compact size means nothing is far from anywhere, and finding a spot near the Parsonage Resale Shop is typically stress-free.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit early in the week after weekends when new donations from summer visitors are often processed and stocked
  • Bring cash as small island shops may have limited card processing capabilities
  • Check for seasonal items in spring and fall when island homeowners donate before and after summer
  • Ask staff about special items or upcoming sales - island shops thrive on personal connections
  • Combine your thrift shopping with other island activities since the shop's location makes it easy to stop by during your explorations

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Kelleys Island Parsonage Resale Shop:

Find More Thrift Stores in Kelleys Island, OH

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Kelleys Island, OH.