My Cousin's Cottage

My Cousin's Cottage brings a charming, curated thrift shopping experience to the heart of downtown Westerville, Ohio. Located at 16 E College Ave, this inviting shop offers a refreshing alternative to typical thrift stores with its carefully selected merchandise and welcoming atmosphere. The store has become a beloved destination for Westerville residents and visitors from surrounding Columbus neighborhoods who appreciate quality secondhand finds without the overwhelming clutter often found at larger thrift operations. Whether you're hunting for unique home décor, vintage treasures, or gently used essentials, My Cousin's Cottage provides a pleasant browsing experience where you can actually see and appreciate each item. The shop's downtown location makes it perfect for combining thrift shopping with a stroll through Westerville's historic Uptown district, grabbing coffee at a nearby café, or exploring the other local boutiques that give this Columbus suburb its distinctive character.

Store Information

16 E College Ave, Westerville, OH 43081

Phone: +1 614-899-6110

Email: mccwesterville@gmail.com

Website: http://www.mycousinscottage.com/

Store Hours

  • Monday: 11AM-6PM
  • Tuesday: 11AM-6PM
  • Wednesday: 11AM-6PM
  • Thursday: 11AM-6PM
  • Friday: 11AM-6PM
  • Saturday: 11AM-6PM
  • Sunday: 1-5PM

What They Sell

My Cousin's Cottage offers a thoughtfully curated selection of gently used and vintage items that reflect the shop's cottage-inspired aesthetic. Shoppers can discover quality home décor pieces, furniture finds, kitchenware, books, and unique collectibles that add character to any space. The merchandise leans toward items with charm and character rather than mass-market goods, making each visit feel like a treasure hunt. The store maintains higher standards for condition and style than typical thrift shops, so you'll find items that are clean, functional, and ready to enjoy in your home.

The Neighborhood

Westerville's Uptown district along College Avenue is the vibrant heart of this historic Columbus suburb, known for its walkable downtown, tree-lined streets, and strong sense of community. My Cousin's Cottage sits just steps from charming local restaurants, coffee shops, and the beautifully maintained Alum Creek Trail. The area attracts both long-time Westerville residents and newcomers who appreciate the small-town atmosphere with big-city convenience, located just minutes from Polaris and I-270.

Parking

Parking for My Cousin's Cottage is straightforward with several options in downtown Westerville. Street parking along College Avenue and nearby side streets is typically available, with both metered and free spots depending on the block. The Uptown district also offers public parking lots within easy walking distance, making it convenient to park once and explore multiple shops during your visit.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit mid-week for a more relaxed shopping experience and first pick of newly processed inventory
  • Take your time browsing—the cottage aesthetic means items are displayed thoughtfully rather than crammed together
  • Ask staff about upcoming sales or special promotions, as local thrift shops often run seasonal discounts
  • Bring measurements if you're furniture shopping, as those perfect vintage pieces go quickly in Westerville
  • Combine your thrift shopping with lunch or coffee at nearby Uptown eateries to make it a full downtown Westerville experience

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near My Cousin's Cottage:

Find More Thrift Stores in Westerville, OH

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Westerville, OH.