Storage Finds

Storage Finds in New Carlisle, Ohio is a hidden gem for treasure hunters and bargain shoppers alike. Located at 135 S Main St, this spacious thrift store offers an eclectic mix of pre-loved items that change regularly, creating a fresh shopping experience with each visit. Unlike conventional thrift shops, Storage Finds specializes in merchandise sourced from abandoned storage units, giving shoppers access to unique collections that might include anything from vintage furniture to collector's items. What makes Storage Finds special is their commitment to fair pricing and organized displays. Local residents of New Carlisle appreciate how the store arranges items by category, making it easy to browse whether you're searching for household essentials, clothing, or unique décor. The friendly staff at Storage Finds are always willing to help you hunt down specific items, adding a personal touch to this community-focused thrift destination.

Store Information

135 S Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344

Phone: +1 326-467-0123

Store Hours

  • Monday: 11AM-8PM
  • Tuesday: 11AM-8PM
  • Wednesday: 11AM-8PM
  • Thursday: 11AM-8PM
  • Friday: 11AM-8PM
  • Saturday: 11AM-8PM
  • Sunday: 11AM-8PM

What They Sell

Storage Finds offers an ever-changing inventory of second-hand treasures sourced primarily from storage unit auctions. Shoppers can discover furniture pieces ranging from vintage to contemporary, home décor items, kitchenware, and functional appliances at a fraction of retail prices. The clothing section features gently-used apparel for all ages, while collectors often browse through displays of books, records, toys, and nostalgic memorabilia. Unlike predictable retail experiences, Storage Finds presents the excitement of discovery with each visit as inventory rotates based on recent auction acquisitions, ensuring something new to explore for New Carlisle residents and visitors alike.

The Neighborhood

Storage Finds sits in the heart of downtown New Carlisle, a charming Ohio community with historic architecture and small-town appeal. The S Main St location is conveniently positioned near Smith Park and the New Carlisle Public Library, making it perfect for combining errands with treasure hunting. This walkable neighborhood features several local eateries and shops, creating a pleasant atmosphere for shoppers exploring New Carlisle's retail offerings.

Parking

Visitors to Storage Finds will find convenient parking options directly in front of the store along S Main St in New Carlisle. The store benefits from several dedicated spots in a small shared lot, with additional free street parking available within easy walking distance. During peak shopping hours (typically weekend afternoons), consider parking along the side streets just off Main for hassle-free access.

Shopping Tips

  • Join their text alert program at checkout to receive notifications when new storage units are processed, giving you first access to fresh inventory.
  • Visit on Wednesdays when Storage Finds typically marks down items that have been in-store for over two weeks.
  • Bring your own reusable bags to easily transport smaller purchases.
  • Don't hesitate to make reasonable offers on higher-priced items, as management often has flexibility on pricing, especially for furniture.
  • Check the front counter for a binder of specialty items not displayed on the floor, including collectibles and higher-value merchandise.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Storage Finds:

Find More Thrift Stores in New Carlisle, OH

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near New Carlisle, OH.