Underground Thrift Store

Underground Thrift Store is a beloved community treasure tucked away at 65 Hicks St in the heart of Brooklyn Heights. Operating as part of Plymouth Church's mission to serve the community, this volunteer-run thrift shop has become a Sunday tradition for savvy Brooklyn shoppers seeking quality secondhand finds while supporting a good cause. The store's unique weekly schedule creates an enthusiastic following of regulars who look forward to their Sunday afternoon treasure hunts. What makes Underground Thrift Store special is its connection to one of Brooklyn's most historic congregations - Plymouth Church, known as the "Grand Central Terminal of the Underground Railroad." Every purchase supports the church's ongoing community programs and charitable work throughout New York. The intimate shopping experience and dedication of volunteers create a welcoming atmosphere where shoppers feel like part of something bigger than just finding a great deal.

Store Information

65 Hicks St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Website: http://www.plymouthchurch.org/undergroundthriftstore/

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: Closed
  • Thursday: Closed
  • Friday: Closed
  • Saturday: Closed
  • Sunday: 12:30-4PM

What They Sell

Underground Thrift Store offers a carefully curated selection of gently used items donated by the generous Brooklyn Heights community. Shoppers can discover quality clothing for all ages, household goods, books, small furniture pieces, and decorative items that reflect the neighborhood's refined taste. Since the store is connected to a historic church community, you'll often find unique vintage pieces, classic wardrobe staples, and quality home goods at remarkably affordable prices. The rotating inventory means each Sunday brings fresh discoveries, from designer clothing labels to charming kitchen accessories and collectibles.

The Neighborhood

Brooklyn Heights is one of New York City's most charming historic neighborhoods, featuring tree-lined streets and stunning 19th-century brownstones. Located near the Brooklyn Promenade with its spectacular Manhattan skyline views, the area around Hicks Street offers a perfect blend of residential tranquility and urban accessibility. The neighborhood is steps from Brooklyn Bridge Park, the vibrant Dumbo district, and countless cafes and restaurants, making Underground Thrift Store an ideal stop during a day exploring brownstone Brooklyn.

Parking

Parking near 65 Hicks Street in Brooklyn Heights typically involves metered street parking on surrounding blocks, with Sunday being advantageous due to relaxed parking restrictions in many zones. The location is also highly accessible via NYC public transportation, with the 2, 3, A, and C trains at nearby Clark Street and High Street stations. Consider walking from Brooklyn Bridge Park or combining your visit with neighborhood exploration to avoid parking hassles altogether.

Shopping Tips

  • Arrive early on Sunday afternoons for the best selection, as devoted regulars know the freshest picks go quickly
  • Bring cash for easier transactions, as this volunteer-run operation may have limited card payment options
  • Check out the book section carefully - Brooklyn Heights donors often contribute impressive literary collections
  • Chat with the friendly volunteers who can share insights about upcoming special donation drives or seasonal items
  • Combine your thrift store visit with a stroll through historic Brooklyn Heights and the nearby Promenade for a perfect Sunday outing

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Underground Thrift Store:

Find More Thrift Stores in Brooklyn, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Brooklyn, NY.