Buffalo Exchange

Buffalo Exchange in Brooklyn, New York is a vibrant fashion resale destination that stands out in the Boerum Hill neighborhood. This well-curated thrift store offers a constantly refreshed selection of contemporary and vintage clothing, making it a favorite among style-conscious Brooklyn shoppers looking for sustainable fashion options. What makes Buffalo Exchange special is their meticulous buy-sell-trade model, ensuring only quality, on-trend pieces make it to the racks. At the Boerum Place location, shoppers can expect a bright, organized space where treasure-hunting is actually enjoyable. Unlike traditional thrift stores, Buffalo Exchange Brooklyn maintains a boutique feel with carefully selected merchandise arranged by style and size. Locals love this particular Buffalo Exchange for its friendly staff who have an excellent eye for fashion and fair pricing, making it a go-to spot for refreshing your wardrobe without breaking the bank or compromising on style.

Store Information

109 Boerum Pl, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Phone: +1 718-403-0490

Website: https://www.buffaloexchange.com/locations/new-york-city/brooklyn-boerum-hill/

Store Hours

  • Monday: 11AM-8PM
  • Tuesday: 11AM-8PM
  • Wednesday: 11AM-8PM
  • Thursday: 11AM-8PM
  • Friday: 11AM-8PM
  • Saturday: 11AM-8PM
  • Sunday: 11AM-7PM

What They Sell

Buffalo Exchange Brooklyn specializes in carefully selected secondhand clothing, shoes, and accessories for men and women. Their inventory ranges from everyday basics to designer finds, vintage treasures, and current season styles—all at a fraction of original retail prices. Fashion-conscious shoppers can discover premium denim, statement jackets, unique dresses, and on-trend accessories that have been hand-selected by their knowledgeable buying team. What sets their merchandise apart is the focus on current styles and quality pieces. Unlike some thrift stores, Buffalo Exchange maintains high standards for condition, relevance, and desirability, making it more like a curated resale boutique than a traditional secondhand shop.

The Neighborhood

Located in Boerum Hill at 109 Boerum Place, this Buffalo Exchange sits in one of Brooklyn's most charming neighborhoods. The area features beautiful brownstones, tree-lined streets, and a vibrant mix of local businesses. It's conveniently situated near Borough Hall and multiple subway lines, making it easily accessible for shoppers from across Brooklyn and Manhattan. The neighborhood's artistic community and fashion-forward residents contribute to the high-quality merchandise found in-store.

Parking

Parking near Buffalo Exchange's Boerum Hill location can be typical of Brooklyn—somewhat challenging but manageable. Street parking is available along Boerum Place and nearby streets, though expect typical urban parking regulations and meters. Many shoppers opt for public transportation instead, as the store is conveniently located near several subway lines. If driving, consider parking a few blocks away in residential areas where restrictions might be more forgiving.

Shopping Tips

  • Sell or trade your gently-used clothing before shopping to earn store credit for up to 50% more value than cash payouts.
  • Visit regularly as inventory changes daily and popular sizes and styles move quickly.
  • Browse all sections regardless of what you're looking for—many shoppers find unexpected treasures in departments they normally wouldn't check.
  • Download the Buffalo Exchange mobile app to check buying conditions before bringing in items to sell.
  • The best designer finds typically appear mid-season when closet clean-outs happen, so keep an eye out in late spring and late fall for premium pieces.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Buffalo Exchange:

Find More Thrift Stores in Brooklyn, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Brooklyn, NY.