Church Attic Thrift Shop

Located in the heart of Amityville, New York, the Church Attic Thrift Shop has been a treasured community resource for bargain hunters and thrift enthusiasts along Broadway. This charming church-run shop embodies the warmth and generosity of small-town Long Island, where every purchase supports the local congregation's community outreach programs. The Church Attic Thrift Shop offers that nostalgic, treasure-hunt shopping experience that keeps regulars coming back week after week. The dedicated volunteers who staff this Amityville thrift store take pride in organizing donations and creating a welcoming atmosphere where neighbors can find quality secondhand items at prices that make sense. Whether you're furnishing a first apartment, looking for unique vintage pieces, or simply enjoy the thrill of discovering hidden gems, this Broadway location delivers an authentic thrift shopping experience rooted in community values.

Store Information

47 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701

Phone: +1 631-264-4555

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: 10AM-3PM
  • Wednesday: 10AM-3PM
  • Thursday: 10AM-3PM
  • Friday: Closed
  • Saturday: 10AM-1PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

As a church-operated thrift shop, the Church Attic Thrift Shop typically offers a curated selection of donated household goods, clothing for the whole family, books, small furniture pieces, and decorative items. Shoppers can expect to find everyday essentials alongside occasional vintage treasures and collectibles. The inventory rotates regularly as community members contribute gently used items, meaning each visit to this Amityville location brings new discoveries. The volunteers carefully sort donations to ensure quality items make it to the sales floor, giving shoppers confidence in their purchases while supporting a good cause.

The Neighborhood

Amityville's Broadway corridor serves as the historic Main Street for this charming Long Island village, combining small-town character with convenient access to both Nassau and Suffolk County shoppers. The Church Attic Thrift Shop sits among local businesses, restaurants, and community institutions that give Amityville its distinctive personality. With nearby Amityville Memorial Park and easy access from Sunrise Highway and Merrick Road, the location is convenient for residents throughout the South Shore looking for quality thrift finds in a walkable, friendly downtown setting.

Parking

Parking near the Church Attic Thrift Shop at 47 Broadway is typical for downtown Amityville, with street parking available along Broadway and surrounding side streets. The area generally offers both metered and free parking zones depending on specific locations. Visitors should plan for a short walk and check posted street signs for any time restrictions or permit requirements during weekday hours.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit on Tuesday mornings right at opening for first pick of newly stocked items from weekend donations
  • Bring cash or check—many church thrift shops prefer traditional payment methods over credit cards
  • Take your time browsing since inventory changes frequently and treasures can hide in unexpected places
  • Ask volunteers about upcoming special sales or bag days when you can fill a bag for one flat price
  • Check back regularly as the small-format store rotates inventory quickly to make room for new donations

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Church Attic Thrift Shop:

Find More Thrift Stores in Amityville, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Amityville, NY.