Church Attic Thrift Shop

Located in the heart of Amityville, New York, the Church Attic Thrift Shop has been a treasured community resource for bargain hunters and thrift enthusiasts along Broadway. This charming church-run shop embodies the warmth and generosity of small-town Long Island, where every purchase supports the local congregation's community outreach programs. The Church Attic Thrift Shop offers that nostalgic, treasure-hunt shopping experience that keeps regulars coming back week after week. The dedicated volunteers who staff this Amityville thrift store take pride in organizing donations and creating a welcoming atmosphere where neighbors can find quality secondhand items at prices that make sense. Whether you're furnishing a first apartment, looking for unique vintage pieces, or simply enjoy the thrill of discovering hidden gems, this Broadway location delivers an authentic thrift shopping experience rooted in community values.