St. Mary’s Thrift Shop

St. Mary's Thrift Shop in Amityville, New York is a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Broadway. This community-focused thrift store offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere where treasure hunters and budget-conscious shoppers alike can discover pre-loved items at remarkable prices. What makes St. Mary's special is their commitment to quality merchandise and personalized service that larger thrift chains simply can't match. The shop is meticulously organized, making your shopping experience enjoyable and efficient. As part of St. Mary's Church, all proceeds support important community outreach programs and services. St. Mary's Thrift Shop has become a beloved Amityville institution where locals regularly stop by to find unique items while contributing to a worthy cause. The friendly volunteers who staff the store are always ready with a smile and helpful advice, creating an experience that keeps shoppers coming back weekend after weekend.

Store Information

175 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701

Phone: +1 631-464-4899

Website: http://stmarysamityville.org/

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: Closed
  • Thursday: Closed
  • Friday: 10:30AM-3PM
  • Saturday: 10:30AM-3PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

St. Mary's Thrift Shop offers an ever-changing inventory of gently-used treasures at budget-friendly prices. Shoppers can discover quality clothing for the whole family, from everyday essentials to occasional designer finds. The store also features a diverse selection of household goods including kitchenware, decorative items, books, and small furniture pieces. Their curated collection often includes vintage treasures, seasonal decor, and unique gift items you won't find elsewhere. The volunteers take care to ensure all merchandise meets their quality standards, so you're always shopping among carefully selected items.

The Neighborhood

Located on Broadway, one of Amityville's main thoroughfares, St. Mary's Thrift Shop is perfectly situated in this charming South Shore Long Island community. The shop is just minutes from the historic Amityville Triangle and the picturesque Amityville Harbor. This convenient location makes it easily accessible for locals and visitors exploring Amityville's quaint downtown area with its mix of small businesses, restaurants, and the famous Amityville Historical Society just a short walk away.

Parking

Visitors to St. Mary's Thrift Shop can typically find convenient street parking along Broadway, especially during their Friday and Saturday operating hours. There's also a small lot adjacent to the church property that patrons can use when shopping. During busier Saturday afternoons, you might need to park a short distance away, but Amityville's walkable downtown makes this a minor inconvenience with the benefit of exploring more of this charming village.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit early on Friday mornings to get first access to newly stocked merchandise and the widest selection of items.
  • Bring cash for easier transactions, though they may accept other payment methods.
  • Don't hesitate to ask volunteers about upcoming sales or when certain types of items might be put out.
  • Check their church website periodically for special sale announcements or seasonal inventory changes.
  • Consider donating quality items you no longer need during store hours to support their community mission and keep the cycle of giving going.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near St. Mary’s Thrift Shop:

Find More Thrift Stores in Amityville, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Amityville, NY.