All That Glitters Is Old

Nestled in the heart of Sullivan County, All That Glitters Is Old brings a carefully curated thrift shopping experience to Hurleyville, New York. This charming boutique-style resale shop lives up to its clever name by offering treasures from bygone eras alongside gently-used contemporary finds. The store's mid-week operating schedule creates an intimate, unhurried shopping atmosphere where customers can leisurely browse without the weekend crowds. Located at 234 Main St Unit 100, All That Glitters Is Old has become a destination for savvy shoppers, vintage enthusiasts, and treasure hunters throughout the Catskills region. Whether you're a longtime Hurleyville resident or just passing through this historic hamlet, the store's welcoming environment and rotating inventory make every visit feel like a new discovery. The staff's passion for sustainable shopping and quality secondhand goods shines through in their thoughtfully arranged displays and attention to detail.