All That Glitters Is Old

Nestled in the heart of Sullivan County, All That Glitters Is Old brings a carefully curated thrift shopping experience to Hurleyville, New York. This charming boutique-style resale shop lives up to its clever name by offering treasures from bygone eras alongside gently-used contemporary finds. The store's mid-week operating schedule creates an intimate, unhurried shopping atmosphere where customers can leisurely browse without the weekend crowds. Located at 234 Main St Unit 100, All That Glitters Is Old has become a destination for savvy shoppers, vintage enthusiasts, and treasure hunters throughout the Catskills region. Whether you're a longtime Hurleyville resident or just passing through this historic hamlet, the store's welcoming environment and rotating inventory make every visit feel like a new discovery. The staff's passion for sustainable shopping and quality secondhand goods shines through in their thoughtfully arranged displays and attention to detail.

Store Information

234 Main St Unit 100, Hurleyville, NY 12747

Phone: +1 845-693-4989

Email: img_2684_580x@2x.heic

Website: http://www.allthatglittersisold.com/

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: 11AM-4PM
  • Thursday: 11AM-4PM
  • Friday: 11AM-4PM
  • Saturday: Closed
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

All That Glitters Is Old specializes in carefully selected secondhand merchandise that ranges from vintage clothing and accessories to home décor and collectibles. Shoppers can expect to discover everything from retro fashion pieces and costume jewelry to decorative items and unique conversation starters. The store's inventory reflects both timeless vintage finds and quality contemporary resale items, ensuring there's something for every taste and budget. The constantly rotating selection means regular visitors are rewarded with fresh discoveries, while the curated approach ensures higher quality standards than typical thrift stores.

The Neighborhood

Hurleyville sits in the scenic Sullivan County Catskills, a community rich in arts and history. This charming hamlet has experienced a cultural renaissance in recent years, with Main Street becoming a hub for small businesses and creative enterprises. The area's proximity to both local residents and seasonal visitors from the greater New York metropolitan area makes it an ideal location for unique shopping destinations. All That Glitters Is Old contributes to Hurleyville's growing reputation as a must-visit stop for antique lovers and bargain hunters exploring upstate New York.

Parking

The Main Street location in downtown Hurleyville typically offers convenient street parking directly in front of or near the store entrance. Unit 100's position on Main St means visitors can easily find curbside spots during the store's operating hours. The small-town atmosphere ensures parking is rarely a challenge, and the walkable downtown area allows you to combine your thrift shopping with visits to other nearby Hurleyville businesses and cafes.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit on Wednesday afternoons for first pick of newly added inventory from weekend sorting and intake
  • Take your time browsing—the mid-week schedule means less crowding and more opportunity to chat with staff about specific items you're seeking
  • Call ahead at +1 845-693-4989 if you're looking for particular vintage items or styles, as the staff may be able to point you to recent arrivals
  • Bring measurements for furniture or clothing sizes since secondhand items can vary significantly from modern sizing standards
  • Follow their website at www.allthatglittersisold.com for updates on special items or seasonal inventory changes

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near All That Glitters Is Old:

Find More Thrift Stores in Hurleyville, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Hurleyville, NY.