Pretty Oddities

Pretty Oddities is Middletown's hidden treasure trove for the curious collector and thrifty shopper alike. Located at 620 North Street in Middletown, New York, this charming secondhand shop lives up to its intriguing name with a carefully curated selection of unique, vintage, and yes, sometimes delightfully odd items. Unlike typical thrift stores, Pretty Oddities creates an intimate shopping experience where every visit unveils something new and unexpected—from vintage clothing and accessories to quirky home décor and collectibles. The shop's thoughtful organization and warm atmosphere make browsing a pleasure rather than a hunt through clutter. Since opening its doors, Pretty Oddities has quickly become a favorite among Middletown locals searching for one-of-a-kind pieces with character and history.