Consignment Shop

Temporarily closed — Consignment Shop is not currently open. Check back soon or call ahead before visiting.

Nestled on Old South Road in the heart of Nantucket, Consignment Shop offers island residents and visitors a unique opportunity to discover pre-loved treasures while embracing sustainable shopping. This locally-focused consignment destination has become a go-to spot for those who appreciate the thrill of the hunt and the satisfaction of finding quality items at accessible prices. Whether you're a year-round Nantucket resident furnishing a cottage or a summer visitor looking for authentic island finds, Consignment Shop provides that curated secondhand shopping experience the island is known for. The store reflects Nantucket's commitment to community and sustainability, offering a rotating inventory that keeps every visit fresh and exciting. Located at 62 Old South Rd, this consignment destination serves as both a practical shopping resource and a treasure trove for those seeking one-of-a-kind pieces with character and history.

Store Information

62 Old South Rd, Nantucket, MA 02554

Phone: +1 508-228-1408

Store Hours

Typical thrift store hours — please call ahead to confirm:

  • Monday–Saturday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
  • Sunday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM

What They Sell

Consignment Shop offers a diverse selection of secondhand and gently-used items that reflect the quality and character Nantucket shoppers expect. From household goods and home décor to clothing, accessories, and seasonal items, the inventory changes regularly as new consignments arrive. Shoppers can expect to find everything from everyday essentials to unique vintage pieces and island-style treasures. The consignment model ensures a curated selection of items that meet quality standards, giving shoppers confidence in their purchases while supporting a more sustainable approach to shopping on Nantucket.

The Neighborhood

Located on Old South Road, Consignment Shop sits in a convenient Nantucket location that's easily accessible from both downtown and residential neighborhoods. This area offers the perfect blend of local charm and practical convenience, with the store positioned along one of the island's main thoroughfares. The surrounding Nantucket community is known for its tight-knit feel, year-round residents, and appreciation for sustainable living, making this consignment shop a natural fit for the neighborhood's values and lifestyle.

Parking

Parking along Old South Road in Nantucket typically includes a combination of street parking and small parking areas near businesses. During peak summer months, arriving earlier in the day often means easier parking access. The location is also accessible by bike, which many Nantucket locals prefer during warmer months. Be mindful of any posted parking restrictions and consider the island's walkable nature when planning your visit.

Shopping Tips

  • Call ahead at 508-228-1408 to confirm hours and ask about recent inventory arrivals or specific items you're seeking.
  • Visit regularly since consignment inventory turns over frequently—what's not there one week might be the perfect find the next.
  • Ask staff about the consignment process if you're looking to sell items, as understanding their acceptance criteria can help you spot quality pieces.
  • Bring cash or check to inquire about payment options, as some smaller Nantucket shops may have limited card processing.
  • Shop during shoulder seasons (late spring or early fall) when you'll find both summer and year-round inventory with fewer crowds.

Before You Go

While specific operating hours for Consignment Shop aren't publicly listed, it's always wise to call ahead at 508-228-1408 before making a special trip, especially during Nantucket's off-season months when island businesses may adjust their schedules. Like many Nantucket consignment shops, the best selection often appears mid-week after new inventory has been processed and priced. Visiting during quieter times allows for a more leisurely browsing experience and better opportunities to chat with staff about incoming items.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Consignment Shop:

Find More Thrift Stores in Nantucket, MA

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Nantucket, MA.