Take It or Leave It

Take It or Leave It is Nantucket's community-driven swap shop operated by the Town of Nantucket's Public Works Department, located at 186 Madaket Rd. This unique island institution embodies the true spirit of reduce, reuse, and recycle, offering residents and visitors a remarkable place to find treasures while keeping usable items out of the landfill. Unlike traditional thrift stores, Take It or Leave It operates on a free exchange basis where islanders can drop off gently used items and take what they need, making it an essential resource for Nantucket's year-round community. The facility sees constant turnover with everything from household goods to furniture, clothing, and seasonal items. Whether you're furnishing a summer rental, looking for unique island finds, or simply embracing sustainable living on Nantucket, this Massachusetts gem offers an ever-changing selection that reflects the island's distinctive character and commitment to environmental stewardship.

Store Information

186 Madaket Rd, Nantucket, MA 02554

Email: dpw@nantucket-ma.gov

Website: http://www.nantucket-ma.gov/237/Public-Works

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: 9AM-1:30PM
  • Thursday: 9AM-1:30PM
  • Friday: 9AM-1:30PM
  • Saturday: 9-11:30AM
  • Sunday: 9-11:30AM

What They Sell

As a municipal swap shop, Take It or Leave It offers an incredibly diverse and ever-changing inventory that reflects island life on Nantucket. Shoppers can discover everything from gently used furniture, household items, kitchen goods, and decorative pieces to clothing for all seasons, books, sporting equipment, and beach gear. The selection varies daily based on community donations, meaning each visit presents new possibilities. You might find high-quality items from seasonal residents downsizing, vintage pieces with island history, or practical everyday goods that perfectly suit Nantucket's coastal lifestyle. The free exchange model means the inventory turns over quickly, especially during peak summer months and seasonal transitions.

The Neighborhood

Located on Madaket Road in the western part of Nantucket Island, Take It or Leave It sits in a practical location that's easily accessible from town and the island's residential areas. The Madaket Road corridor connects Nantucket's historic downtown to the laid-back western beaches, making this swap shop a convenient stop for islanders running errands. The area maintains that authentic Nantucket feel, away from the tourist bustle, serving the tight-knit year-round community that makes this Massachusetts island special.

Parking

Parking at Take It or Leave It is straightforward, with an accessible lot at the Public Works facility on Madaket Road. The location offers convenient on-site parking for visitors dropping off donations or browsing the available items. Given Nantucket's compact size and the swap shop's practical location, parking is generally hassle-free, even during busy island summer months. Just be mindful of other islanders coming and going during peak morning hours.

Shopping Tips

  • Arrive early in the day, especially on Wednesdays and weekend mornings, to see the freshest donations before items get claimed
  • Bring reusable bags or be prepared to carry items, as this is a no-frills swap facility
  • Visit regularly since inventory changes daily—what's not there one day might appear the next
  • Respect the island community spirit by only taking what you genuinely need and donating quality items in return
  • Check seasonal timing: late spring and early fall often bring excellent finds as seasonal residents transition on and off the island

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Take It or Leave It:

Find More Thrift Stores in Nantucket, MA

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Nantucket, MA.