Tosha's one of every thing

Welcome to Tosha's One of Every Thing, Spencer's most eclectic treasure trove nestled on Park Hill Drive. This charming thrift store lives up to its name by offering an impressively diverse collection of items that make every visit a new adventure. Owned and operated by Tosha herself, this Spencer gem stands out for its meticulous organization and friendly atmosphere that keeps locals returning week after week. Unlike larger chain thrift stores, Tosha's maintains that personal touch where the owner often greets customers by name and can tell you the story behind many of the more unique finds. Located in the heart of Spencer, Indiana, the store has become not just a shopping destination but a community hub where Spencer residents exchange stories as freely as they do treasures.

Store Information

1899 Park Hill Dr, Spencer, IN 47460

Phone: +1 812-585-5147

Store Hours

  • Monday: 9AM-5PM
  • Tuesday: 9AM-5PM
  • Wednesday: 9AM-5PM
  • Thursday: 9AM-5PM
  • Friday: 9AM-5PM
  • Saturday: 9AM-5PM
  • Sunday: 9AM-5PM

What They Sell

True to its name, Tosha's One of Every Thing offers an impressive range of pre-loved treasures that changes weekly. Shoppers can discover everything from vintage clothing and accessories to furniture, home décor, kitchenware, books, and collectibles. The store particularly shines in its selection of retro items from the 60s through the 90s, with many pieces maintaining excellent condition. Tosha has a keen eye for quality, ensuring that while prices remain thrift-store friendly, the merchandise rises above typical secondhand expectations. Local artisans occasionally consign handcrafted items here as well, adding unique Spencer-made creations to the mix.

The Neighborhood

Spencer, Indiana offers that quintessential small-town charm that makes Tosha's One of Every Thing feel right at home. Located near the scenic White River and just a short drive from McCormick's Creek State Park, the store sits in a peaceful residential area of Park Hill Drive. The neighborhood maintains that friendly Midwest atmosphere where everyone seems to know each other. Visitors appreciate the easy access from downtown Spencer, making it a convenient stop while exploring this historic Owen County seat.

Parking

Parking at Tosha's One of Every Thing is hassle-free with a small dedicated lot directly in front of the store that typically accommodates 5-6 vehicles. During busier shopping days, ample street parking is available along Park Hill Drive. The wide, suburban street design makes for easy pull-in parking within a short walking distance to the store entrance, a convenience that Spencer shoppers particularly appreciate.

Shopping Tips

  • Join the 'Tosha's Treasures' text alert list at checkout to receive notifications when new shipments arrive – Spencer locals swear by this to snag the best items.
  • Bring your own reusable bags to carry your finds and receive a small discount at checkout.
  • Don't be shy about making reasonable offers on furniture pieces, especially those that have been in the store longer than two weeks.
  • Check the color-coded tag system – items with blue tags are often discounted by 25% on Wednesdays.
  • The back corner of the store is where Tosha displays her newest and most unique vintage items, so make that your first stop if you're hunting for something special in Spencer.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Tosha's one of every thing:

Find More Thrift Stores in Spencer, IN

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Spencer, IN.