The Amish Mall

The Amish Mall in Elkhart, Indiana offers a unique shopping experience that combines thrift store finds with authentic Amish-crafted goods. Located on W Bristol Street, this hidden gem has become a favorite among locals seeking quality secondhand items and handcrafted treasures. The spacious interior features well-organized departments that make browsing enjoyable, whether you're hunting for vintage clothing, household items, or handmade Amish furniture and crafts. What sets The Amish Mall apart from typical thrift stores is their commitment to showcasing traditional Amish workmanship alongside carefully curated secondhand goods. Elkhart residents appreciate the friendly staff who are always ready to share the stories behind special items or help you find exactly what you're looking for in this distinctive community marketplace.

Store Information

1216 W Bristol St, Elkhart, IN 46514

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: 10AM-7PM
  • Wednesday: 10AM-7PM
  • Thursday: 10AM-7PM
  • Friday: 10AM-7PM
  • Saturday: 10AM-7PM
  • Sunday: 12-5PM

What They Sell

The Amish Mall offers an eclectic mix of secondhand treasures and authentic Amish-crafted items that you won't find in typical thrift stores. Shoppers can browse through quality used furniture, home décor, kitchenware, and clothing at affordable prices. The store particularly shines with its selection of handcrafted Amish furniture pieces, quilts, and homemade goods that showcase traditional craftsmanship. Many customers return regularly to check for unique finds like vintage collectibles, antique tools, and seasonal items that frequently rotate through their inventory as new donations and consignments arrive.

The Neighborhood

Located in the heart of Elkhart's west side retail district, The Amish Mall sits along the bustling Bristol Street corridor that serves as a main commercial artery for the city. This neighborhood blends Elkhart's industrial heritage with its proximity to Amish country, creating a unique cultural crossroads. Shoppers will find the location conveniently accessible from both downtown Elkhart and the surrounding suburban communities, with nearby restaurants and complementary businesses making it an ideal destination for a day of exploring local commerce.

Parking

The Amish Mall features a spacious parking lot directly in front of the store on Bristol Street, making it convenient for shoppers to access. During peak weekend shopping hours, you may find the front spaces filling quickly, but there's typically ample overflow parking available along the side of the building. The lot is well-maintained year-round, with good lighting for evening shoppers visiting during Elkhart's winter months.

Shopping Tips

  • Sign up for The Amish Mall's email list at checkout to receive notifications about special sales and newly arrived Amish crafts.
  • Tuesday mornings offer the freshest selection after Monday's restocking day.
  • Bring measurements for furniture shopping, as many unique pieces move quickly in this Elkhart favorite.
  • Don't hesitate to ask staff about upcoming inventory—they often know when certain Amish craftsmen will be bringing in new work.
  • The last hour before closing on Saturdays sometimes yields additional discounts on select items that staff don't want to store over the weekend.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near The Amish Mall:

Find More Thrift Stores in Elkhart, IN

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Elkhart, IN.