Anything & Everything
Anything & Everything lives up to its name as Paoli's treasure trove of secondhand finds and unexpected discoveries. Located at 114 S Court St in the heart of downtown Paoli, Indiana, this thrift store has become a beloved shopping destination for residents and visitors exploring Orange County. The store offers that classic thrift hunting experience where patience and persistence pay off with unique finds you won't see anywhere else. Whether you're a seasoned thrifter or just beginning to explore the world of secondhand shopping, Anything & Everything provides an authentic, community-centered atmosphere that reflects the welcoming spirit of Paoli. The constantly rotating inventory means each visit brings new possibilities, making it worth stopping by regularly to see what's recently arrived on the shelves.
Store Information
114 S Court St, Paoli, IN 47454Phone: +1 812-723-1433
Store Hours
- Monday: Closed
- Tuesday: 12-5PM
- Wednesday: 12-5PM
- Thursday: 12-5PM
- Friday: 12-5PM
- Saturday: 12-2PM
- Sunday: Closed
What They Sell
As a general thrift store, Anything & Everything offers a diverse mix of secondhand merchandise that truly encompasses their all-inclusive name. Shoppers can browse through clothing for all ages, household items, kitchenware, décor, books, and various everyday essentials at budget-friendly prices. The selection reflects the donations and finds from the local Paoli community, giving the inventory an authentic Southern Indiana character. You'll discover everything from practical necessities to quirky vintage pieces, with the kind of variety that makes thrift shopping an adventure rather than just an errand.
The Neighborhood
Downtown Paoli, the Orange County seat, offers charming small-town Indiana character with its historic courthouse square and locally-owned businesses. Anything & Everything sits right on Court Street, making it easily accessible whether you're running errands around the square, grabbing lunch at nearby restaurants, or exploring the antique shops and local stores that give Paoli its unique appeal. The central location makes it a natural stop during any downtown visit.
Parking
Located on South Court Street in downtown Paoli, Anything & Everything benefits from typical small-town parking convenience. Street parking is generally available along Court Street and surrounding downtown blocks, and the relaxed pace of Paoli means finding a spot near the store is usually straightforward. The central courthouse square location makes it easy to park once and visit multiple shops on foot.
Shopping Tips
- Visit regularly since thrift store inventory changes constantly based on new donations and acquisitions
- Don't hesitate to dig through shelves and racks thoroughly – the best finds are often tucked away waiting to be discovered
- Bring cash as smaller thrift stores in rural Indiana communities may not always accept cards
- Ask the staff if they have any upcoming sales or discount days to maximize your savings
- Keep an open mind about repurposing items – something marketed for one use might be perfect for a creative DIY project
Nearby Thrift Stores
Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Anything & Everything:
- Tacos Treasures Thrift Shop — West Baden Springs, IN
- Regeneration Thrift Store — Mitchell, IN
- God's Place Quarter Store — Bedford, IN
- St. Vincent de Paul Society — Bedford, IN
- Goodwill Store — Bedford, IN
- Perfect Cents Thrift Store — Salem, IN
- Goodwill Store — Salem, IN
- Old Capitol Thrift Store — Corydon, IN
Find More Thrift Stores in Paoli, IN
Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Paoli, IN.