Nearly New Thrift Shop

Nearly New Thrift Shop, located at 5800 Overseas Highway in Marathon, Florida, is a beloved community treasure operated in support of St. Columba Episcopal Church. This charming thrift store offers Florida Keys residents and visitors a unique shopping experience where every purchase supports local ministry and outreach programs. The shop reflects the laid-back, community-focused spirit that makes the Middle Keys special, with friendly volunteers who create a welcoming atmosphere for treasure hunters and bargain seekers alike. Whether you're a Marathon local furnishing a home, a seasonal resident updating your wardrobe, or a visitor looking for unique finds, Nearly New Thrift Shop provides an affordable and meaningful way to shop while giving back to the community.

Store Information

5800 Overseas Hwy STE 35, Marathon, FL 33050

Phone: +1 305-743-6412

Email: office@stcolumbamarathon.org

Website: http://www.stcolumbamarathon.org/

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: Closed
  • Thursday: 10AM-2PM
  • Friday: 10AM-2PM
  • Saturday: 10AM-2PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

Nearly New Thrift Shop offers a rotating selection of quality secondhand items donated by generous community members throughout the Florida Keys. Shoppers can discover gently used clothing suitable for the tropical climate, household goods, decorative items, books, and various treasures that reflect the eclectic nature of Keys living. The inventory changes regularly as new donations arrive, making each visit a fresh shopping adventure. From beach-appropriate casual wear to kitchen essentials and unique collectibles, the shop caters to the practical needs and treasure-hunting desires of Marathon shoppers.

The Neighborhood

Situated on the iconic Overseas Highway in Marathon, this thrift shop serves the heart of the Florida Keys community. Marathon is known for its perfect blend of local charm and tourist appeal, positioned halfway between Key Largo and Key West. The location offers easy access for residents throughout the Middle Keys, with nearby attractions like Sombrero Beach, Crane Point Museum, and the Marathon Community Park. The convenient highway location makes it an easy stop for both locals running errands and visitors exploring the Keys.

Parking

Parking at Nearly New Thrift Shop is typically straightforward, with available spaces in the shopping plaza along the Overseas Highway. The location offers convenient off-street parking, allowing shoppers to easily access the store without the hassle of searching for street parking. As with most Marathon locations, parking is generally accessible, though weekend mornings during peak season may see more activity in the area.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit on Thursday mornings right at opening for first access to freshly sorted donations and new inventory
  • Bring cash for the smoothest transaction, as this volunteer-run shop may have limited payment options
  • Check their connection to St. Columba Episcopal Church's website for any special sale days or extended hours during peak season
  • Don't hesitate to ask volunteers about specific items you're seeking – they often know what's newly arrived
  • Remember that purchases directly support local community outreach programs, making your bargain finds even more rewarding

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Nearly New Thrift Shop:

Find More Thrift Stores in Marathon, FL

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Marathon, FL.