Sanibel Treasures and Consignment

Sanibel Treasures and Consignment brings the thrill of treasure hunting to one of Florida's most beloved barrier islands. Located at 2250 Periwinkle Way in the heart of Sanibel, this consignment shop offers islanders and visitors alike a refreshing alternative to typical resort shopping. The store curates an ever-changing selection of quality pre-owned items that reflect the coastal lifestyle and sophisticated tastes of the Sanibel community. Whether you're a year-round resident looking to refresh your home décor or a seasonal visitor seeking unique finds, Sanibel Treasures and Consignment delivers that perfect blend of discovery and value. The relaxed island atmosphere extends right into the shopping experience, where browsing feels leisurely rather than rushed. Many locals appreciate having a quality consignment option that aligns with sustainable shopping values while keeping items circulating within the community.

Store Information

2250 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33903

Phone: +1 239-910-7333

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: 10AM-1PM
  • Wednesday: Closed
  • Thursday: Closed
  • Friday: Closed
  • Saturday: Closed
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

As a consignment store on Sanibel Island, you can expect to find items that reflect the coastal Florida lifestyle and the tastes of the island's discerning residents. The inventory typically includes gently used home furnishings, beach-appropriate décor, tropical-themed accessories, and seasonal items that suit island living. Given Sanibel's upscale reputation, consignors often bring quality pieces ranging from coastal cottage style to more sophisticated furnishings. The selection changes regularly as new items arrive from local consignors, so each visit offers fresh possibilities for discovering that perfect piece.

The Neighborhood

Periwinkle Way serves as Sanibel's main commercial corridor, making Sanibel Treasures and Consignment easily accessible whether you're coming from the causeway or heading back from the beach. This Florida Gulf Coast island is known for its shell-covered beaches, wildlife refuges, and laid-back atmosphere. The store sits among local shops and restaurants that cater to both the island's residential community and its steady stream of nature-loving tourists, making it a convenient stop during your Sanibel errands or explorations.

Parking

Periwinkle Way locations typically offer convenient parking options, whether in dedicated lots or shared plaza spaces. Sanibel's relaxed pace means parking is generally more accessible than mainland shopping areas, though during peak season (winter months), arriving earlier in the day can ensure easier access. The island's friendly atmosphere extends to parking, with most shoppers finding the experience stress-free compared to typical Florida retail areas.

Shopping Tips

  • Call ahead at 239-910-7333 to confirm hours before making the trip, especially during off-season months when island businesses may adjust schedules
  • Visit regularly since consignment inventory turns over frequently, and today's empty spot could hold tomorrow's perfect find
  • Ask staff when new items typically hit the floor so you can time your visits for first access to fresh merchandise
  • Bring measurements if you're furniture shopping—island living spaces often have unique dimensions
  • Consider the seasonal timing: snowbird departures in spring often mean quality consignments from residents heading north

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Sanibel Treasures and Consignment:

Find More Thrift Stores in Sanibel, FL

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Sanibel, FL.