The Arbitrarium

The Arbitrarium in Colorado Springs is a delightfully eclectic thrift destination tucked away on East Platte Avenue. Unlike typical secondhand shops, this hidden gem offers a carefully curated collection of vintage treasures, unique oddities, and gently-used items that spark curiosity and imagination. The shop's distinctive name hints at its arbitrated selection—each piece thoughtfully chosen to create an atmosphere where discovery feels magical. Colorado Springs residents frequent The Arbitrarium not just for sustainable shopping, but for the immersive experience of wandering through themed displays and unexpected finds that change with each visit. The friendly staff's passion for their collection makes browsing the compact but richly-stocked space feel like exploring a cabinet of curiosities rather than simply shopping.

Store Information

2360 E Platte Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80909

Website: https://www.thearbitrarium.space/

5★ average across 45 reviews on Google

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: 1-7PM
  • Thursday: 1-7PM
  • Friday: 1-7PM
  • Saturday: 1-7PM
  • Sunday: 1-5PM

What They Sell

The Arbitrarium specializes in the unexpected and the extraordinary. Shoppers can discover vintage clothing spanning multiple decades, from 70s bohemian pieces to 90s nostalgia wear, alongside classic accessories and jewelry that add character to any collection. The store also features an impressive array of home decor items including quirky lamps, framed artwork, and conversation-starting curiosities that you won't find in mainstream retail. For the literary-minded, their book section offers everything from dog-eared classics to obscure titles, while vinyl enthusiasts can often uncover records ranging from classic rock to local Colorado artists.

The Neighborhood

Located in the bustling East Platte corridor of Colorado Springs, The Arbitrarium sits in a diverse commercial district that blends local businesses with residential charm. Just minutes from downtown and the historic Old North End, this accessible location puts shoppers near popular spots like Patty Jewett Golf Course and the Bon Shopping Center. The area's unpretentious vibe perfectly complements the thrift store's approachable atmosphere, making it a favorite destination for both nearby residents and visitors exploring different neighborhoods of Colorado Springs.

Parking

Parking at The Arbitrarium is straightforward with dedicated spots in the small lot directly in front of the store on East Platte Avenue. During busier weekend hours, additional street parking can be found along the surrounding side streets. The wide boulevard design of Platte Avenue makes access simple from either direction, and most visitors find parking within a minute's walk of the entrance.

Shopping Tips

  • Follow The Arbitrarium's social media accounts for announcements about new inventory drops and special themed collections.
  • Bring cash for potential discounts, though cards are also accepted for larger purchases.
  • Don't hesitate to ask staff about items in the back—some of the best finds haven't even made it to the floor yet.
  • Visit during mid-week for the most relaxed shopping experience and first pick of newly processed items.
  • Check the small bulletin board near the register for information about upcoming local events and complementary businesses in Colorado Springs.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near The Arbitrarium:

Find More Thrift Stores in Colorado Springs, CO

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Colorado Springs, CO.