Buffalo Exchange

Buffalo Exchange in Hillcrest, San Diego is a vibrant secondhand fashion destination where style meets sustainability. Unlike typical thrift stores, this trendy resale shop curates a carefully selected collection of contemporary and vintage clothing, accessories, and footwear that appeals to fashion-forward shoppers. Located on bustling Fifth Avenue in the heart of Hillcrest, Buffalo Exchange San Diego stands out for its buy-sell-trade model that keeps inventory fresh daily and offers shoppers the opportunity to sell their own gently used items for cash or store credit. The bright, organized space makes treasure hunting enjoyable, with items arranged by type and size rather than the chaotic jumble found at many thrift stores.

Store Information

3862 Fifth Ave, San Diego, California 92103

Phone: +1 619-298-4411

Website:

Store Hours

  • Monday: 11AM-8PM
  • Tuesday: 11AM-8PM
  • Wednesday: 11AM-8PM
  • Thursday: 11AM-8PM
  • Friday: 11AM-8PM
  • Saturday: 11AM-8PM
  • Sunday: 11AM-7PM

What They Sell

Buffalo Exchange specializes in curated secondhand clothing and accessories for all genders, with a focus on current styles, vintage finds, and unique pieces you won't find elsewhere. Their inventory ranges from everyday basics and contemporary brands to designer labels and one-of-a-kind vintage treasures. Unlike many thrift stores, Buffalo Exchange is highly selective about what they accept, ensuring higher quality merchandise. Shoppers can find everything from jeans and graphic tees to formal wear, outerwear, shoes, jewelry, and bags—all at prices significantly lower than retail.

The Neighborhood

The Hillcrest neighborhood of San Diego, California is known for its inclusive atmosphere, eclectic dining scene, and independent businesses. Buffalo Exchange sits on Fifth Avenue, one of the main commercial strips in this vibrant community. Shoppers will find themselves just steps away from Balboa Park, numerous coffee shops, and popular eateries. The area's walkable streets, LGBTQ+ friendly environment, and central location make it a favorite shopping destination for locals from across San Diego County.

Parking

Parking near Buffalo Exchange in Hillcrest can be challenging during peak hours. Street parking is available along Fifth Avenue and side streets, though it's often metered with time limits. There are several paid lots within walking distance, including the Hillcrest DMV lot when it's not during business hours. Many shoppers find success parking a block or two away on residential streets and enjoying a short walk to the store.

Shopping Tips

  • Sell your clothes before shopping to earn store credit worth 50% of what Buffalo Exchange will price your items (vs. 30% for cash payment), essentially getting you better deals.
  • Visit on weekdays before 3PM for a calmer shopping experience and first pick of newly-priced merchandise.
  • Check the sale racks at the back of the store for additional discounts on already affordable items.
  • Don't hesitate on items you love—due to the one-of-a-kind nature of inventory, that perfect piece might be gone if you wait.
  • Follow Buffalo Exchange San Diego on social media to learn about special promotions and seasonal clearance events.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Buffalo Exchange:

Find More Thrift Stores in San Diego, California

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near San Diego, California.