Choose Your Treasure

Choose Your Treasure stands as one of Monterey, California's hidden gems for thrift enthusiasts and bargain hunters alike. Located on historic Pearl Street in the heart of downtown, this carefully curated thrift store offers an ever-changing selection of secondhand treasures that reflect the eclectic spirit of the Monterey Peninsula. What sets Choose Your Treasure apart is their commitment to quality over quantity – each item is thoughtfully selected and displayed, creating a boutique-like shopping experience rather than the overwhelming chaos often found at larger thrift chains. The store's intimate atmosphere encourages leisurely browsing, allowing customers to discover unique finds that tell their own stories. Whether you're a local resident seeking sustainable shopping options or a visitor looking for authentic Monterey memorabilia, Choose Your Treasure provides that perfect blend of affordability and surprise that makes thrift shopping such an addictive treasure hunt.

Store Information

211 Pearl St, Monterey, California 93940

Phone: +1 831-747-1633

Store Hours

  • Monday: 11AM-7PM
  • Tuesday: 11AM-7PM
  • Wednesday: 11AM-7PM
  • Thursday: 11AM-7PM
  • Friday: 11AM-7PM
  • Saturday: 11AM-7PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

Choose Your Treasure specializes in carefully selected secondhand merchandise that spans multiple categories to appeal to diverse tastes and needs. Shoppers can discover vintage clothing and accessories, gently used home décor items, books, small furniture pieces, and unique collectibles that capture the coastal California lifestyle. The store maintains higher quality standards than typical thrift shops, ensuring that items are clean, functional, and worth the treasure hunt. Regular inventory turnover means there's always something new to discover, from retro fashion pieces to one-of-a-kind household items that add character to any home.

The Neighborhood

Situated on Pearl Street in downtown Monterey, Choose Your Treasure benefits from one of California's most charming historic districts. Just blocks from Fisherman's Wharf and the world-famous Monterey Bay Aquarium, the store sits amid a walkable neighborhood filled with local cafes, art galleries, and specialty shops. This prime location makes it easy for both tourists exploring Monterey's attractions and locals running errands to stop in and browse for unexpected finds.

Parking

Downtown Monterey street parking is typically available along Pearl Street and surrounding blocks, with a mix of metered and time-limited spaces. The area also offers several nearby public parking lots within easy walking distance. Since Choose Your Treasure is located in the walkable downtown core, many visitors combine their thrift shopping with other Pearl Street activities, making parking efficient for multiple stops.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit on weekday mornings when new inventory is freshly displayed and you'll have first pick of recent donations
  • Bring cash for the best negotiating power, especially on larger items or multiple purchases
  • Check back frequently since inventory changes rapidly and that perfect piece might arrive any day
  • Ask staff about upcoming donation drops or special collections – they often know when unique items are coming in
  • Take time to explore every corner since the best treasures are often tucked away in unexpected spots

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Choose Your Treasure:

Find More Thrift Stores in Monterey, California

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Monterey, California.