Forgotten Finds

Forgotten Finds on NW 23rd St in Bethany, OK is one of those hidden gem thrift stores that rewards the curious shopper willing to dig a little deeper. With a name that perfectly captures the spirit of secondhand treasure hunting, this store has built a loyal following among Bethany residents and bargain hunters from across the Oklahoma City metro area. The atmosphere feels like a well-organized attic of someone with great taste — you never quite know what you'll uncover, and that's exactly the point. With consistent hours six days a week and a relaxed Sunday window for afternoon browsing, Forgotten Finds has made itself a reliable destination for both casual shoppers and dedicated thrifters. The staff keeps inventory rotating, which means repeat visits almost always turn up something new. Whether you're furnishing a first apartment, hunting vintage pieces, or just stretching your shopping budget further, Forgotten Finds delivers the kind of experience that keeps Bethany shoppers coming back.

Store Information

7457 NW 23rd St, Bethany, OK 73008

Phone: +1 405-914-6388

4.9★ average across 54 reviews on Google

Store Hours

  • Monday: 9AM-6:30PM
  • Tuesday: 9AM-6:30PM
  • Wednesday: 9AM-6:30PM
  • Thursday: 9AM-6:30PM
  • Friday: 9AM-6:30PM
  • Saturday: 9AM-6:30PM
  • Sunday: 12-4PM

What They Sell

Forgotten Finds carries the kind of varied secondhand inventory that makes thrift shopping genuinely exciting. Shoppers can expect a rotating mix of clothing and accessories, household goods, kitchenware, books, décor, furniture pieces, and collectibles — the sort of eclectic mix that reflects donations from real Bethany-area households. Quality tends to be solid, with items spanning everyday practical finds to the occasional vintage or name-brand piece hiding among the racks. Because inventory turns over regularly, no two visits to this Bethany thrift store feel quite the same. Dedicated secondhand shoppers will appreciate that Forgotten Finds carries a broad enough selection to make every trip worthwhile, whether you're searching for something specific or simply open to discovery.

The Neighborhood

Forgotten Finds is situated along NW 23rd St in Bethany, OK, a welcoming suburban community just west of Oklahoma City. The area blends residential neighborhoods with practical retail corridors, drawing shoppers from Bethany, Warr Acres, and the broader OKC westside. The NW 23rd corridor is well-traveled and easy to access, making this thrift store a convenient stop whether you're running errands locally or making a dedicated trip across town.

Parking

Located along NW 23rd St in Bethany, OK, Forgotten Finds benefits from the practical parking typical of this commercial corridor. Shoppers can generally expect on-site lot parking or accessible off-street options near the storefront. Street parking along NW 23rd St is usually available as a secondary option during peak hours.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit on weekday mornings when inventory is freshest and the store is less crowded — serious thrifters in the Bethany area know that early birds find the best pieces before the weekend rush.
  • Come with an open mind and no strict agenda. Forgotten Finds rewards flexible shoppers; some of the best discoveries happen when you weren't looking for anything in particular.
  • Check back frequently — because secondhand inventory rotates constantly, a visit every week or two dramatically increases your odds of scoring something special.
  • Bring measurements for furniture or home goods if you're shopping for a specific space; having your room dimensions handy saves you from a return trip.
  • Don't overlook the less glamorous sections like kitchenware or books — these areas at thrift stores like Forgotten Finds often hide high-quality, lightly used items at a fraction of retail price.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Forgotten Finds:

Find More Thrift Stores in Bethany, OK

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Bethany, OK.