Payless Thrift Store

Payless Thrift Store on South Pennsylvania Avenue has built a loyal following among Oklahoma City bargain hunters who know that great finds don't require a big budget. With 184 reviews and counting, this store has clearly earned its place as a go-to destination for secondhand shoppers on the south side of OKC. The store lives up to its name, consistently offering prices that make thrifting genuinely worthwhile rather than just marginally cheaper than retail. Shopping at Payless Thrift Store feels like a proper treasure hunt. The inventory turns over regularly, which means repeat visitors are almost always rewarded with something new. Whether you're furnishing an apartment, refreshing your wardrobe, or hunting for something specific, the selection at this Oklahoma City location gives you real options without the overwhelm of some larger chains. It's the kind of neighborhood thrift store that feels personal and community-rooted.

Store Information

4640 S Pennsylvania Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73119

Phone: +1 405-681-1112

4.1★ average across 207 reviews on Google

Store Hours

  • Monday: 9AM-7PM
  • Tuesday: 9AM-7PM
  • Wednesday: 9AM-7PM
  • Thursday: 9AM-7PM
  • Friday: 9AM-7PM
  • Saturday: 9AM-7PM
  • Sunday: 10AM-6PM

What They Sell

Payless Thrift Store carries the full range of secondhand goods you'd hope to find at a solid neighborhood thrift shop. Expect rotating racks of clothing for men, women, and kids, alongside housewares, kitchenware, small appliances, books, and decorative items. Furniture and larger household pieces show up periodically depending on donations. The key here is variety — inventory changes constantly based on community donations, so no two visits look exactly alike. Shoppers hunting for vintage pieces, everyday basics, or gently used home goods will find Payless worth a regular stop.

The Neighborhood

Located on South Pennsylvania Avenue in Oklahoma City, OK 73119, Payless Thrift Store sits in a well-traveled south OKC corridor with easy access from surrounding neighborhoods like Edgemere Park and the broader Capitol Hill area. South Penn is a practical, working-class stretch with plenty of everyday businesses nearby, making it easy to combine a thrifting run with other errands. The location is accessible from I-240 and draws shoppers from across the south side of the metro.

Parking

Payless Thrift Store is located in a retail corridor along South Pennsylvania Avenue, where off-street parking is typically available in a front or adjacent lot — standard for this style of Oklahoma City strip-style commercial address. Parking is generally straightforward and free, without the congestion you'd find at larger shopping centers. Arriving during off-peak hours makes it even easier.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit early in the week — Monday and Tuesday mornings are often when newly donated and processed items make it onto the floor, giving you first pick before weekend crowds move through.
  • Check back often since inventory at Payless Thrift Store turns over faster than you might expect; a weekly visit dramatically increases your odds of finding something useful.
  • Go in with a general list but stay flexible — the best thrift store scores in Oklahoma City happen when you keep an open mind about brands, sizes, and styles.
  • Inspect items carefully before purchasing, especially electronics and anything with mechanical parts, since all sales are typically final at thrift stores.
  • Don't overlook the housewares and kitchen sections — these often yield excellent value on items that see very light use before being donated, and Payless tends to price them very competitively.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Payless Thrift Store:

Find More Thrift Stores in Oklahoma City, OK

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Oklahoma City, OK.