Treasure Island

Treasure Island has become a beloved fixture in Spearfish, SD, offering shoppers a genuine treasure-hunting experience right on N 5th Street. Whether you're a longtime local or just passing through the Black Hills region, this secondhand shop delivers the kind of eclectic, ever-changing inventory that keeps people coming back week after week. The name says it all — you never quite know what you'll uncover on any given visit. With 46 community reviews already backing its reputation, Treasure Island has earned genuine trust among Spearfish residents. The store carries a welcoming, unhurried atmosphere that sets it apart from big-box resale chains. Shoppers appreciate the thoughtfully organized space, fair pricing, and the sense that real care goes into what ends up on the shelves. For budget-conscious families, college students, vintage hunters, and everyday bargain seekers in the Spearfish area, Treasure Island is the kind of local gem that makes secondhand shopping genuinely enjoyable.

Store Information

714 N 5th St, Spearfish, SD 57783

Phone: +1 605-722-1046

3.9★ average across 51 reviews on Google

Store Hours

  • Monday: 9AM-5PM
  • Tuesday: 9AM-5PM
  • Wednesday: 9AM-5PM
  • Thursday: 9AM-5PM
  • Friday: 9AM-5PM
  • Saturday: 10AM-4PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

Treasure Island stocks the kind of wide-ranging secondhand inventory that rewards repeat visits. Shoppers can expect to find clothing for men, women, and children, household goods, kitchenware, books, décor, furniture pieces, and collectibles — all at prices that make secondhand the smart choice. The selection rotates regularly, meaning each trip through the doors of this Spearfish thrift store brings fresh possibilities. Whether you're furnishing a first apartment, hunting for vintage finds, or simply stretching your dollar further, Treasure Island's shelves rarely disappoint.

The Neighborhood

Treasure Island sits along N 5th Street in Spearfish, SD, a charming small city nestled at the edge of the Black Hills and the northern gateway to Spearfish Canyon. The area has a tight-knit, community-first feel, with locally owned businesses lining the streets nearby. Its central location makes it easy to stop in while running errands around town or exploring downtown Spearfish.

Parking

N 5th Street in Spearfish typically offers convenient street parking directly in front of and near the store. The area is generally low-traffic and easy to navigate, making quick stops just as practical as longer browsing sessions. Accessibility is straightforward, and you shouldn't have trouble finding a spot close to the entrance.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit early in the week — Monday and Tuesday mornings tend to bring freshly added inventory, giving you first pick before items disappear.
  • Come with an open mind. Treasure Island rewards flexible shoppers; if you're hunting for something specific, call ahead at +1 605-722-1046 to ask about current stock.
  • Check every section, even ones outside your usual interest — great finds in Spearfish thrift stores often hide in unexpected spots.
  • Bring cash as a backup, since some smaller secondhand shops in SD prefer it for smoother transactions.
  • Make it a regular habit. Because inventory changes constantly, shoppers who stop in every week or two consistently score the best deals at Treasure Island.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Treasure Island:

Find More Thrift Stores in Spearfish, SD

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Spearfish, SD.