Cindy’s Closet

Cindy's Closet has become a beloved hidden gem in Amherst, VA, offering shoppers a curated secondhand shopping experience that feels more like browsing a friend's well-organized wardrobe than digging through a typical thrift store. Located at 120 2nd St in the heart of Amherst, this community staple draws in regulars who appreciate the thoughtfully arranged merchandise and the warm, personal atmosphere that only a smaller, independent thrift shop can offer. What sets Cindy's Closet apart from larger chain thrift stores is the sense of discovery that comes with every visit. Shoppers consistently return because the inventory turns over regularly, meaning there's always something new waiting to be found. Whether you're a dedicated thrifter hunting for vintage treasures or simply looking to stretch your budget without sacrificing style, Cindy's Closet in Amherst delivers a refreshingly personal shopping experience that keeps the local community coming back week after week.

Store Information

120 2nd St, Amherst, VA 24521

Phone: +1 434-426-9101

5★ average across 25 reviews on Google

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: 10AM-5PM
  • Thursday: 10AM-7PM
  • Friday: 10AM-5PM
  • Saturday: 10AM-5PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

Cindy's Closet carries a rotating selection of secondhand goods spanning clothing, accessories, housewares, and everyday essentials. Shoppers in Amherst, VA frequent the store for gently used women's and men's apparel, shoes, handbags, and home décor pieces at a fraction of retail prices. Because inventory arrives continuously from local donations, you'll often find name-brand clothing alongside unique vintage finds and practical household items. The eclectic mix means no two visits are ever quite the same, making each trip its own little treasure hunt.

The Neighborhood

Cindy's Closet sits along 2nd Street in downtown Amherst, VA, a charming small-town setting that blends historic character with easy accessibility. Amherst's compact, walkable downtown makes it simple to combine a thrift run with other local errands or a bite to eat nearby. The tight-knit community atmosphere of Amherst means shoppers are greeted as neighbors, not just customers.

Parking

Parking near Cindy's Closet on 2nd Street in downtown Amherst, VA is generally straightforward. Street parking along 2nd Street and surrounding blocks is typically available and free, which is one of the perks of shopping in a small-town downtown. Arriving mid-morning on weekdays usually guarantees a spot just steps from the front door.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit on Thursday evenings when the store stays open until 7PM — it's typically less crowded than Saturday, giving you more space and time to dig through the racks without the weekend rush.
  • Come back frequently since Cindy's Closet receives new donations regularly, and inventory in Amherst thrift stores like this one can turn over quickly — a must-pass item one week may be gone the next.
  • Check clothing and accessories first thing when you arrive, as popular sizes and name-brand pieces tend to move fast among the store's loyal regulars.
  • Bring cash as a backup, since smaller independent thrift shops occasionally have payment preferences or connectivity limitations.
  • Don't overlook the housewares and home goods section — some of the most underrated finds at Cindy's Closet are the everyday items that can refresh your home décor at a fraction of the cost.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Cindy’s Closet:

Find More Thrift Stores in Amherst, VA

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Amherst, VA.