Encore Resale Store

Store Information

Phone: +1 715-779-3455

4★ average across 27 reviews on Google

Store Hours

• Monday: Closed
• Tuesday: Closed
• Wednesday: Closed
• Thursday: Closed
• Friday: 10AM-4PM
• Saturday: 10AM-4PM
• Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

Encore Resale Store offers a rotating mix of secondhand goods that reflects the eclectic, outdoorsy character of the Bayfield, WI community. Shoppers can expect to find clothing for all seasons — a must in northern Wisconsin — alongside household items, books, décor, and collectibles. Because inventory turns over regularly, each visit feels fresh and full of possibility. The secondhand selection at Encore tends to lean toward practical, well-maintained items donated by locals who care about quality. From functional kitchenware and furniture pieces to outdoor gear and vintage finds, there's genuine variety here for budget-conscious shoppers and treasure hunters alike.

The Neighborhood

Encore Resale Store sits on South Broad Street in Bayfield, WI, one of the most picturesque small towns on Lake Superior's Apostle Islands shoreline. The downtown area is compact and walkable, with independent shops, galleries, and eateries nearby. Its location makes it easy to combine a thrift run with a stroll to the waterfront or a visit to other local spots — perfectly woven into the fabric of this tight-knit lakeside community.

Parking

South Broad Street in downtown Bayfield, WI typically offers convenient on-street parking right along the storefront, and the compact downtown layout means you're rarely far from a spot. Bayfield's small-town scale keeps parking stress-free, especially during the store's Friday and Saturday hours. Arrive early on busy summer weekends to snag a spot closest to the store.

Shopping Tips

• Make the most of your visit to Encore Resale Store in Bayfield, WI with these insider tips:
• Visit Friday morning when the store opens at 10AM — this is your best shot at first pick on any newly stocked items before the weekend crowd arrives.
• Go in with an open mind. Encore's inventory is community-sourced, so the best finds are often unexpected — leave room in your bag for surprises.
• Since hours are limited to just two days a week, plan ahead and don't assume you can swing by mid-week; Friday and Saturday 10AM–4PM are the only windows to shop.
• If you're visiting Bayfield for a weekend getaway, layer your Encore stop into a broader downtown walk — the store's South Broad Street location puts you close to cafes and waterfront spots to round out the day.
• Check back regularly if you're a local — thrift inventory changes constantly, and what wasn't there last Saturday could be exactly what you're looking for the next.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Encore Resale Store:

• ABC Thrift Shop — Washburn, WI
• Goodwill — Ashland, WI
• Partners of Tamarack Health Thrift Store — Ashland, WI
• The Bargain Hut — Ashland, WI
• Fig Leaf Thrift Store — Iron River, WI
• St. Vincent de Paul Society Thrift Store — Ironwood, MI
• Gogebic Area Thrift — Ironwood, MI
• Temperance Traders — Schroeder, MN

Find More Thrift Stores in Bayfield, WI

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Bayfield, WI.

• All Thrift Stores in Bayfield, WI
• All Thrift Stores in WI
• Search All Thrift Stores Nationwide