Second Hand Sue's

Second Hand Sue's is one of Sister Bay's most beloved hidden gems, tucked along the scenic North Bay Shore Drive in the heart of Door County, WI. Whether you're a year-round resident hunting for everyday essentials or a seasonal visitor hoping to find something uniquely Wisconsin to take home, this shop delivers the kind of relaxed, treasure-hunt experience that keeps shoppers coming back. The curated mix of secondhand goods feels thoughtfully organized rather than overwhelming, making it easy to browse even on a quick stop. What sets Second Hand Sue's apart is its small-town charm and the genuine sense that someone cares about what ends up on the shelves. Sister Bay locals have come to trust this store as a reliable source for quality finds at fair prices. With 20 customer reviews already building its reputation, it's clear that shoppers in the Sister Bay, WI area appreciate having a neighborhood thrift store that feels personal and community-rooted rather than corporate and impersonal.

Store Information

10744 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234

Phone: +1 920-854-3310

3.8★ average across 22 reviews on Google

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: 10AM-5PM
  • Wednesday: 10AM-5PM
  • Thursday: 10AM-5PM
  • Friday: 10AM-5PM
  • Saturday: 10AM-5PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

Second Hand Sue's offers a rotating selection of secondhand goods that spans clothing, housewares, furniture, books, décor, and everyday essentials. Because inventory turns over regularly, no two visits are quite the same — which is exactly the appeal for dedicated thrift shoppers in the Sister Bay area. You're just as likely to uncover a quality piece of Door County cottage decor as you are a barely-worn jacket or a useful kitchen find. The shop tends to reflect the tastes and lifestyles of the surrounding Door County community, meaning you'll often find practical, well-maintained items alongside the occasional standout vintage piece. It's the kind of thrift store where patience and a good eye genuinely pay off.

The Neighborhood

Second Hand Sue's sits along North Bay Shore Drive in Sister Bay, WI, a charming village that anchors the northern end of the Door County Peninsula. Known for its waterfront views, boutique shops, and welcoming small-town atmosphere, Sister Bay draws both locals and visitors from Green Bay and beyond. The store's location makes it an easy addition to any shopping day in the village, especially when combined with a stroll along the bay.

Parking

North Bay Shore Drive in Sister Bay, WI typically offers accessible street parking along the roadway, with additional options often available in nearby village lots. Parking in this part of Sister Bay is generally manageable outside of peak summer weekends. Arriving a few minutes early during busy Door County tourist season gives you the best chance of finding a spot close to the store.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit early in the week — Tuesday is the first day Second Hand Sue's opens after the weekend, which often means freshly stocked shelves and the best selection before regulars have a chance to pick through inventory.
  • Come with an open mind and no strict list — like all great thrift stores, Second Hand Sue's rewards flexible shoppers who browse with curiosity rather than tunnel vision.
  • Check back often throughout the season, especially if you're a Door County regular — inventory at Second Hand Sue's turns over frequently, so a visit that comes up empty one week might yield a great find the next.
  • If you spot something you love, don't hesitate — secondhand items are one of a kind, and there's no guarantee it'll still be there if you think it over and return later.
  • Call ahead at +1 920-854-3310 before making a special trip, particularly early or late in the season, to confirm hours or ask about specific item availability.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Second Hand Sue's:

Find More Thrift Stores in Sister Bay, WI

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Sister Bay, WI.