The do over

Temporarily closed — The do over is not currently open. Check back soon or call ahead before visiting.

The Do Over is a thrift store tucked away on Prentice Street South in Clayton, WI, bringing the joy of secondhand shopping to this quiet corner of Polk County. Whether you're a seasoned thrifter or just discovering the thrill of the hunt, The Do Over offers that classic small-town shop experience where every visit can turn up something unexpected and wonderful. The name says it all — this is a place where goods get a second chance, and where shoppers can find real value without the big-box price tags. Clayton's tight-knit community has a gem in The Do Over, a store that reflects the resourceful, down-to-earth spirit of rural Wisconsin. Browsing here feels personal and unhurried, a refreshing contrast to chain retail. Supporting The Do Over means keeping dollars local and keeping perfectly useful items out of landfills — a win for your wallet and for the community.

Store Information

107 Prentice St S, Clayton, WI 54004

Phone: +1 715-554-0227

Store Hours

Typical thrift store hours — please call ahead to confirm:

  • Monday–Saturday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
  • Sunday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM

What They Sell

As a full-service thrift and secondhand goods shop, The Do Over carries the kind of rotating, ever-changing inventory that keeps regulars coming back week after week. Shoppers can expect to find clothing for all ages, household items, kitchenware, furniture, décor, books, and the occasional hidden treasure — vintage finds, collectibles, and gently used tools or sporting goods that fit the active outdoor lifestyle of the Clayton, WI area. Because inventory is donated and constantly refreshed, no two visits are ever quite the same.

The Neighborhood

Clayton, WI sits in the scenic St. Croix River valley region of Polk County, surrounded by lakes, forests, and the kind of small-town charm that draws visitors from the Twin Cities metro and beyond. Prentice Street South is a low-traffic, accessible location that makes stopping in easy for locals running errands or travelers passing through northwestern Wisconsin on their way to nearby recreational destinations.

Parking

The Do Over's location at 107 Prentice St S in Clayton, WI is typical of small-town Wisconsin storefronts, where parking is generally relaxed and stress-free. Street parking along Prentice Street is your most likely option, and given the low traffic volume in this part of Clayton, finding a spot close to the door should rarely be a challenge.

Shopping Tips

  • Call ahead at +1 715-554-0227 to confirm hours and ask if new donations have recently been processed — fresh stock days are gold for thrifters.
  • Visit regularly rather than once in a while; The Do Over's inventory turns over continuously, so a shelf that was empty last week may be loaded this week.
  • Come with an open mind and no strict shopping list — the best finds at any secondhand store happen when you're browsing freely rather than hunting for one specific item.
  • Inspect items carefully but don't overlook pieces that need minor cleaning or a small repair; in thrift shopping, a little effort can turn a dollar item into something you'll use for years.
  • Get friendly with the staff — in a small Clayton, WI shop like The Do Over, the people behind the counter often know what's in the back and what's coming in soon.

Before You Go

Current hours for The Do Over haven't been listed publicly yet, so it's best to call ahead at +1 715-554-0227 before making the trip, especially if you're coming from outside Clayton. Like many independent thrift stores in small Wisconsin communities, hours may vary seasonally or around local events. A quick phone call can also give you a heads-up if a new batch of donations has just been sorted — often the best time to find fresh inventory.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near The do over:

Find More Thrift Stores in Clayton, WI

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Clayton, WI.