St Peter Thrift Shop Annex

St. Peter Thrift Shop Annex is a beloved community treasure tucked away on Jack Frost Street in Eagle River, WI. Run in connection with St. Peter's parish, this shop carries the kind of genuine small-town warmth that's hard to find anywhere else — staffed by dedicated volunteers who take pride in curating a clean, well-organized shopping floor. Every purchase supports a meaningful local cause, which makes browsing the aisles feel as good as it sounds. Shopping at the St. Peter Thrift Shop Annex in Eagle River is a relaxed, unhurried experience perfect for the Northwoods pace of life. With a loyal base of 18 community reviewers, this little shop has earned its reputation as a go-to destination for budget-conscious locals and cabin-goers alike. Whether you're furnishing a lakeside retreat or just hunting for a hidden gem, this annex delivers the authentic thrift experience that big-box resale chains simply can't replicate.

Store Information

414 Jack Frost St, Eagle River, WI 54521

Phone: +1 715-479-6393

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: 10AM-2PM
  • Thursday: Closed
  • Friday: Closed
  • Saturday: 10AM-2PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

St. Peter Thrift Shop Annex offers a rotating selection of secondhand goods that changes frequently, keeping every visit feeling fresh. Shoppers can expect to find gently used clothing for all ages, household items, kitchenware, books, décor, and small furniture pieces — all at thrift-friendly prices. Given Eagle River's resort community character, you'll often come across quality cabin and outdoor lifestyle items donated by seasonal residents, making this a particularly worthwhile stop for Northwoods home finds.

The Neighborhood

Eagle River, WI sits in the heart of Vilas County, surrounded by the famous Northwoods lakes and pine forests that draw visitors year-round. The Jack Frost Street location feels right at home in this tight-knit community, just minutes from downtown Eagle River's shops and services. For locals and seasonal residents passing through, it's a convenient and familiar stop worth making.

Parking

The Jack Frost Street location in Eagle River offers convenient street parking directly in front of the shop, typical of this neighborhood's layout. Pulling up and walking in is generally easy and stress-free. Given the shop's compact hours and community scale, you're unlikely to face any parking challenges during your visit.

Shopping Tips

  • Arrive early on Saturdays — the first hour after the 10 AM opening is when freshly rotated inventory is most plentiful and the best selections are still available.
  • Visit on both open days if you can; Wednesday and Saturday restocks sometimes differ, giving you two distinct shopping experiences each week.
  • Bring cash if possible, as smaller volunteer-run shops like St. Peter Thrift Shop Annex may have limited card processing options.
  • Keep an eye out for seasonal donations — Eagle River's cabin community means quality outdoor gear, home goods, and lakeshore items often turn up unexpectedly.
  • Don't overlook the books and small décor sections; these areas are frequently refreshed and often hide underpriced gems that fly under most shoppers' radar.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near St Peter Thrift Shop Annex:

Find More Thrift Stores in Eagle River, WI

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Eagle River, WI.