St John's Thrift Store

St. John's Thrift Store on West North Water Street in New London, WI is one of those community gems that regulars keep coming back to week after week. Rooted in the spirit of giving and sustainability, this store offers an ever-changing selection of secondhand goods at prices that make stretching a budget feel easy and even fun. The welcoming atmosphere and well-organized layout make browsing a pleasure rather than a chore. What sets St. John's Thrift Store apart is the care that goes into how the shop is run. Items are thoughtfully sorted and displayed, making it easier to find what you're looking for without digging through chaos. With 26 customer reviews and a loyal local following, this New London thrift destination has clearly earned its place in the community. Whether you're hunting for a specific item or just enjoy the thrill of the find, St. John's delivers a satisfying secondhand shopping experience every visit.

Store Information

107 W North Water St, New London, WI 54961

Phone: +1 920-982-4141

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: 10AM-4PM
  • Wednesday: 10AM-4PM
  • Thursday: 10AM-4PM
  • Friday: 10AM-2PM
  • Saturday: 10AM-2PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

Shoppers at St. John's Thrift Store in New London, WI can expect a rotating mix of everyday secondhand goods including clothing for men, women, and children, household items, kitchenware, décor, books, and small furniture pieces. Because inventory turns over regularly through community donations, no two visits look exactly alike. The quality of items tends to be solid — this isn't a discard pile, it's a curated donation-based selection. Bargain hunters particularly love the store for finding gently used home goods and seasonal clothing at a fraction of retail prices.

The Neighborhood

Located on West North Water Street in the heart of New London, WI, St. John's Thrift Store sits in a walkable area along the Wolf River corridor. New London is a tight-knit Fox Valley community where local businesses are genuinely supported. The central location makes it easy to combine a thrift run with other errands downtown, and the area has a friendly, small-town energy that makes shopping feel unhurried.

Parking

West North Water Street in downtown New London, WI typically offers convenient on-street parking along the block, making a quick stop at St. John's Thrift Store easy and hassle-free. Parallel parking spots are generally available along the street, and the downtown area is compact enough that a short walk from a nearby side street is never a problem.

Shopping Tips

  • Make the most of your visit to St. John's Thrift Store in New London, WI with these insider tips:
  • Visit early in the week — Tuesday and Wednesday mornings often mean freshly stocked shelves after weekend donation processing, giving you first pick of new arrivals.
  • Arrive with time to browse — the inventory changes constantly, so what wasn't there last week might be waiting for you today. Rushing through means missing hidden finds.
  • Check every section even if you came for something specific — great secondhand scores often show up in unexpected spots, from a quality kitchen item in the décor section to a like-new jacket tucked in with everyday clothes.
  • Keep the Friday and Saturday 2PM closing time in mind and plan to arrive at least an hour early to shop comfortably without feeling rushed.
  • Bring cash as a backup — while many thrift stores accept cards, smaller community shops sometimes prefer cash or may have minimum purchase requirements for card transactions.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near St John's Thrift Store:

Find More Thrift Stores in New London, WI

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near New London, WI.