Left Behind LLC

Left Behind LLC is a hidden gem tucked along West Wisconsin Avenue in the heart of Appleton, WI. This secondhand shop lives up to its name — it's full of items that others left behind, waiting for someone new to give them a second life. Whether you're a seasoned thrift hunter or just starting to explore sustainable shopping, Left Behind offers a curated selection of pre-loved goods at prices that make it worth the trip. What sets Left Behind LLC apart is its manageable, browsable layout that doesn't overwhelm. Shoppers in Appleton appreciate a thrift experience where you can actually dig through inventory without feeling lost in an enormous warehouse. The store has built a loyal local following — 19 reviews and counting — thanks to its friendly atmosphere and the genuine thrill of the find. It's the kind of place where you walk in looking for one thing and leave with something you didn't know you needed.

Store Information

205 W Wisconsin Ave, Appleton, WI 54911

Phone: +1 920-202-3202

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: 9AM-3PM
  • Wednesday: 9AM-6PM
  • Thursday: 9AM-6PM
  • Friday: 9AM-6PM
  • Saturday: 9AM-4PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

Left Behind LLC offers a rotating selection of secondhand goods spanning everyday essentials and unexpected treasures. Shoppers can expect to find clothing, housewares, décor, books, small furniture, and an assortment of general merchandise — the kind of eclectic mix that defines a true thrift experience. Because inventory turns over regularly, no two visits are quite the same. That unpredictability is exactly the appeal for Appleton-area thrift enthusiasts who return often to see what's new on the shelves.

The Neighborhood

Located on W Wisconsin Ave in downtown Appleton, WI, Left Behind LLC sits in a vibrant corridor that blends local businesses, dining, and community energy. Appleton's Wisconsin Avenue is a well-traveled stretch that's easy to reach from surrounding neighborhoods and the broader Fox Cities region. The area has a walkable, small-city feel that makes combining a thrift run with other local errands a natural choice.

Parking

West Wisconsin Avenue in Appleton typically offers on-street parking along the block, making a quick stop at Left Behind LLC relatively straightforward. Depending on the time of day, metered or free street spots are usually available nearby. It's worth circling the immediate block if the closest spots are taken, as parking in this part of Appleton is generally accessible.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit Wednesday or Thursday when inventory is most likely to have been refreshed and competition from weekend shoppers is lower.
  • Check the store more than once — Left Behind LLC's secondhand stock changes constantly, so a return visit a week later can reveal completely different finds.
  • Come with an open mind and no strict agenda; the best thrift scores at Left Behind happen when you're browsing freely rather than searching for one specific item.
  • Arrive early on Saturdays if you're hunting for furniture, housewares, or higher-demand pieces, as the best items tend to move quickly on weekend mornings.
  • Don't overlook the less obvious sections — smaller décor items, books, and miscellaneous goods at Left Behind LLC often hide the most interesting and underpriced discoveries.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Left Behind LLC:

Find More Thrift Stores in Appleton, WI

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Appleton, WI.