SuperThrift

SuperThrift on Milwaukee's northwest side has built a reputation as one of the go-to secondhand destinations in the 53225 zip code. With over 126 customer reviews already logged, this store has clearly found its footing with local bargain hunters and treasure seekers who keep coming back. The shopping floor offers that classic thrift store energy — the kind where you genuinely never know what you'll find, and that unpredictability is exactly the point. Shopping at SuperThrift feels like a community experience. Located at 5333 N 91st St, it draws a steady mix of budget-conscious families, vintage enthusiasts, and resellers who appreciate the rotating inventory and accessible price points. Whether you're furnishing an apartment on a tight budget or hunting for something genuinely unique, SuperThrift Milwaukee delivers a hands-on, rewarding experience that big-box retailers simply can't replicate.

Store Information

5333 N 91st St, Milwaukee, WI 53225

Phone: +1 414-763-7333

Store Hours

  • Monday: 10AM-7PM
  • Tuesday: 10AM-7PM
  • Wednesday: 10AM-7PM
  • Thursday: 10AM-7PM
  • Friday: 10AM-7PM
  • Saturday: 10AM-7PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

As a full-service thrift and secondhand goods store, SuperThrift Milwaukee typically stocks a wide-ranging mix of clothing for men, women, and children, along with household goods, kitchenware, small appliances, books, toys, and furniture. The inventory turns over regularly, which means frequent shoppers are often rewarded with fresh finds. You're just as likely to uncover a barely-used kitchen gadget as you are a vintage jacket or a gently loved piece of furniture — all at prices that make the hunt worthwhile.

The Neighborhood

SuperThrift sits in the heart of Milwaukee's northwest side, a working-class neighborhood known for its tight-knit community and practical, everyday shopping culture. The N 91st Street corridor is easily accessible from major routes connecting neighborhoods like Menomonee Falls and Wauwatosa, making it a convenient stop for shoppers across the greater Milwaukee, WI area looking to stretch their dollar without driving far.

Parking

Given its location on N 91st St in a typical Milwaukee retail corridor, SuperThrift likely offers accessible off-street parking directly in front of or adjacent to the store. Parking is generally easy in this part of Milwaukee's northwest side, with ample lot space that makes loading up larger finds — furniture, bags of clothing — a straightforward experience.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit early in the week — Tuesday and Wednesday are often when newly donated items hit the floor after weekend processing, giving you first pick of fresh inventory.
  • Check tags carefully — SuperThrift may use a color-tag rotation system where certain colors are discounted on specific days, so ask staff which tags are on sale when you arrive.
  • Bring measurements for furniture or large items — it's easy to fall in love with a piece on the spot, so knowing your space dimensions ahead of time saves trips back.
  • Don't skip the housewares section — Milwaukee thrift shoppers often focus on clothing, which means kitchenware, tools, and home goods can sit longer and offer exceptional value.
  • Go in with an open mind — the best SuperThrift finds rarely match what you originally planned to look for, so leave room for happy surprises.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near SuperThrift:

Find More Thrift Stores in Milwaukee, WI

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Milwaukee, WI.