Cathy’s

Cathy's in Pittsburgh is a hidden gem nestled along Forbes Avenue, offering a curated shopping experience that blends vintage treasures with contemporary secondhand finds. Unlike typical thrift stores, Cathy's creates an intimate boutique atmosphere where each item feels specially selected rather than simply donated. Pittsburgh students and young professionals frequent this Oakland neighborhood staple for its affordable fashion pieces, unique home goods, and the friendly, personalized service from staff who know their inventory inside and out. What sets Cathy's apart is their commitment to quality over quantity. Rather than overwhelming racks, shoppers at this Forbes Avenue location will discover thoughtfully arranged displays that change regularly, encouraging repeat visits to this Pittsburgh thrift destination. The store's Instagram-worthy aesthetic makes it not just a shopping trip but a treasure hunt that locals recommend to anyone seeking sustainable fashion options in Pittsburgh's vibrant Oakland district.

Store Information

3717 Forbes Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15213

Phone: +1 412-834-6653

Website: https://www.instagram.com/cathys.oakland/

Store Hours

  • Monday: 11AM-9PM
  • Tuesday: 11AM-9PM
  • Wednesday: 11AM-9PM
  • Thursday: 11AM-9PM
  • Friday: 11AM-9PM
  • Saturday: 11AM-9PM
  • Sunday: 11AM-9PM

What They Sell

Cathy's offers a carefully curated selection of pre-loved clothing with an emphasis on vintage and on-trend pieces that appeal to Pittsburgh's fashion-forward crowd. Shoppers can discover everything from classic 90s windbreakers and retro graphic tees to gently-used contemporary brands at a fraction of retail prices. Beyond clothing, Cathy's typically stocks an eclectic mix of accessories, jewelry, small home goods, and occasionally vinyl records and books that reflect the diverse tastes of the Oakland neighborhood.

The Neighborhood

Located in Pittsburgh's lively Oakland neighborhood, Cathy's sits in the heart of the city's academic and cultural center. Forbes Avenue buzzes with energy from nearby University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon students, creating a youthful, creative atmosphere. The area boasts convenient access to Schenley Plaza, Carnegie Museums, and numerous cafes and restaurants, making it easy to extend your thrift shopping adventure into a full day of Pittsburgh exploration.

Parking

Parking near Cathy's on Forbes Avenue can be competitive given its Oakland location. Street parking with meters is available along Forbes and adjacent streets, but spots fill quickly during peak hours. Several public parking garages are within walking distance, including the Soldiers and Sailors garage. Many shoppers opt to use Pittsburgh's public transit options, as several bus routes service this central Oakland location.

Shopping Tips

  • Follow Cathy's Instagram account (@cathys.oakland) to see newly arrived items and be first to know about special sales events in Pittsburgh.
  • Visit on Wednesdays when they typically refresh their inventory with new finds.
  • Build rapport with staff for insider tips on upcoming merchandise they've spotted while sorting.
  • Look carefully through accessories bins, which often contain hidden designer pieces at thrift prices.
  • Bring cash for smaller purchases to speed up checkout, though they do accept cards for larger buys.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Cathy’s:

Find More Thrift Stores in Pittsburgh, PA

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Pittsburgh, PA.