Church of St. Mary Thrift Shop

The Church of St. Mary Thrift Shop stands as a beloved community treasure in East Islip, New York. Located at 87 W Main St, this welcoming thrift shop operates as part of St. Mary's Church outreach program, combining charitable mission with affordable shopping. The store offers a carefully curated selection of pre-loved items in a bright, organized space that makes browsing enjoyable and purposeful. What sets the Church of St. Mary Thrift Shop apart is not just the quality finds at bargain prices, but the knowledge that purchases directly support various community assistance programs. East Islip residents frequently mention the friendly volunteers who create a warm shopping atmosphere while helping customers find exactly what they need.

Store Information

87 W Main St, East Islip, NY 11730

Phone: +1 631-277-2524

Email: rectory@stmaryei.org

Website: https://www.stmaryei.org/outreach/

Store Hours

  • Monday: 10AM-4PM
  • Tuesday: 10AM-4PM
  • Wednesday: 10AM-4PM
  • Thursday: 10AM-4PM
  • Friday: 10AM-4PM
  • Saturday: 9AM-3PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

The Church of St. Mary Thrift Shop offers a diverse inventory that typically includes gently-used clothing for all ages, from everyday wear to occasional formal pieces. Household goods form another significant category, with kitchenware, decorative items, and small furniture pieces regularly available. Shoppers can also discover books, toys, seasonal decorations, and occasionally vintage treasures or collectibles. All merchandise undergoes careful inspection to ensure quality, with many items arriving as nearly-new donations from supportive East Islip community members.

The Neighborhood

East Islip is a charming South Shore community in Suffolk County with a relaxed suburban feel. The Church of St. Mary Thrift Shop sits conveniently on West Main Street, the heart of East Islip's small but vibrant downtown area. Shoppers appreciate its proximity to Islip Town Hall, the East Islip Public Library, and several local eateries. The neighborhood exudes a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere that perfectly complements the thrift shop's community-focused mission.

Parking

Visitors to the Church of St. Mary Thrift Shop will find convenient parking options directly on the premises, with additional street parking available along West Main Street. During peak shopping hours, especially Saturday mornings, the nearby church parking areas may provide overflow space. Most shoppers report easily finding parking within a short walking distance to the store entrance, making it accessible for quick visits or longer browsing sessions.

Shopping Tips

  • Join their mailing list or follow social media updates for announcements about special sales and themed donation weeks.
  • Shop mid-week for first access to newly displayed merchandise, as volunteers typically process weekend donations on Mondays and Tuesdays.
  • Build rapport with the volunteer staff who can alert you when items matching your interests arrive.
  • Bring your own reusable shopping bags to make carrying purchases easier while supporting their eco-friendly initiatives.
  • Consider donating quality items you no longer need when shopping—many regulars maintain this giving cycle that strengthens the East Islip community.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Church of St. Mary Thrift Shop:

Find More Thrift Stores in East Islip, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near East Islip, NY.