The What Not Shop

Nestled in the scenic Catskill Mountains, The What Not Shop offers treasure hunters in Tannersville, New York a delightful browsing experience filled with unexpected finds. This charming thrift store embodies the eclectic spirit of its name, with an ever-changing inventory that keeps locals and mountain visitors coming back to see what's new. The shop has become a beloved part of the Tannersville community, where sustainable shopping meets small-town charm. Whether you're a year-round resident furnishing a mountain home or a weekend visitor looking for unique souvenirs, The What Not Shop provides an authentic thrift store experience in the heart of the Northern Catskills. The relaxed, unhurried atmosphere makes it easy to spend time exploring every corner of the shop, and the personal touch you'll find here reflects the welcoming character of Tannersville itself.

Store Information

6058 NY-23A, Tannersville, NY 12485

Store Hours

Typical thrift store hours — please call ahead to confirm:

  • Monday–Saturday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
  • Sunday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM

What They Sell

The What Not Shop lives up to its whimsical name by offering a diverse array of secondhand treasures that reflect the eclectic needs of mountain living. Shoppers can discover everything from practical household items and vintage kitchenware to unique decorative pieces perfect for Catskills cabins and country homes. The inventory typically includes furniture, home décor, books, small appliances, and various collectibles. Like many thrift stores in resort communities, the selection changes with the seasons as both locals and vacationers contribute donations, meaning each visit offers fresh discoveries and one-of-a-kind finds you won't see anywhere else.

The Neighborhood

The What Not Shop is located along Route 23A in Tannersville, New York, a picturesque mountain village known as the "Painted Village in the Sky." This charming Catskills community sits at 2,000 feet elevation and serves as a gateway to Hunter Mountain ski resort. The area attracts outdoor enthusiasts year-round, from skiers in winter to hikers and leaf-peepers in fall. Downtown Tannersville's walkable main street features local shops, cafes, and that distinctive small-town mountain character that makes browsing The What Not Shop part of a perfect Catskills day trip.

Parking

Parking along Route 23A in Tannersville is generally straightforward, with typical options including roadside parking or a dedicated lot near The What Not Shop. The area isn't heavily congested except during peak ski season weekends, so finding a spot is usually hassle-free. As with any mountain highway location, be mindful of winter weather conditions and leave extra space for snow removal areas during the colder months.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit during off-peak hours on weekdays for the most relaxed browsing experience and undiscovered deals
  • Bring cash as a backup payment method, since smaller mountain-town shops may have limited card processing options
  • Check back frequently since inventory turnover in resort-area thrift stores tends to be high with seasonal visitors
  • Ask locals or staff about the best donation days when fresh merchandise typically hits the floor
  • Bring measurements if you're furniture shopping for a specific space in your home or cabin

Before You Go

While specific operating hours for The What Not Shop aren't publicly listed, it's always wise to call ahead or check locally before making a special trip to this Tannersville location. Mountain-area thrift stores sometimes adjust their schedules seasonally to match tourism patterns, with more consistent hours during peak ski season and summer months. Weekday mornings typically offer the most relaxed shopping experience with fewer crowds, while fresh inventory often appears early in the week after weekend donations. Local residents recommend confirming current hours with nearby Tannersville businesses if you're planning a visit.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near The What Not Shop:

Find More Thrift Stores in Tannersville, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Tannersville, NY.