The What Not Shop

Nestled in the scenic Catskill Mountains, The What Not Shop offers treasure hunters in Tannersville, New York a delightful browsing experience filled with unexpected finds. This charming thrift store embodies the eclectic spirit of its name, with an ever-changing inventory that keeps locals and mountain visitors coming back to see what's new. The shop has become a beloved part of the Tannersville community, where sustainable shopping meets small-town charm. Whether you're a year-round resident furnishing a mountain home or a weekend visitor looking for unique souvenirs, The What Not Shop provides an authentic thrift store experience in the heart of the Northern Catskills. The relaxed, unhurried atmosphere makes it easy to spend time exploring every corner of the shop, and the personal touch you'll find here reflects the welcoming character of Tannersville itself.