Tin Lilly

Tin Lilly stands as a hidden gem along Middle Road in Bayport, offering treasure hunters and budget-conscious shoppers a carefully curated thrifting experience. This charming store has carved out a special niche in the Long Island thrifting scene, where locals know they can find quality secondhand items without the overwhelming clutter often found at larger thrift chains. The welcoming atmosphere at Tin Lilly makes browsing a pleasure rather than a chore, with thoughtfully organized displays that make it easy to spot that perfect vintage piece or everyday essential. What sets Tin Lilly apart in the Bayport community is their commitment to creating a boutique-style thrift shopping experience, where each visit feels like a curated adventure through carefully selected pre-loved treasures.

Store Information

587 Middle Rd, Bayport, NY 11705

Phone: +1 631-419-6460

Store Hours

Typical thrift store hours — please call ahead to confirm:

  • Monday–Saturday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
  • Sunday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM

What They Sell

While specific categories aren't detailed, Tin Lilly typically offers an eclectic mix of quality secondhand items that reflect the refined tastes of the Bayport community. Shoppers can expect to discover everything from vintage clothing and accessories to unique home décor pieces, books, and household essentials. The store's careful curation means you'll find items in excellent condition, often featuring name brands and unique pieces that tell their own stories, making each shopping trip a delightful treasure hunt.

The Neighborhood

Located in the heart of Bayport, New York, Tin Lilly sits perfectly positioned to serve both locals and visitors exploring this charming South Shore community. The Middle Road location offers easy access for shoppers traveling from nearby Patchogue, Blue Point, and Sayville, while being just minutes from the scenic Bayport-Blue Point Library and local parks. This family-friendly neighborhood maintains a small-town feel while offering the convenience of various shopping and dining options within walking distance.

Parking

The Middle Road location in Bayport typically offers convenient parking options common to this area's retail establishments. Most businesses along this stretch provide either dedicated parking lots or ample street parking for customers. The area is generally easy to navigate, making it simple to pop in for a quick browse or spend more time treasure hunting without worrying about parking restrictions.

Shopping Tips

  • Call ahead at 631-419-6460 to confirm hours and ask about new inventory arrivals for the best selection
  • Visit regularly since thrift store inventory changes frequently, and the best items often sell quickly
  • Bring cash as some smaller thrift stores prefer cash transactions or may offer cash discounts
  • Take your time browsing – Tin Lilly's curated approach means hidden gems might be tucked throughout the store
  • Follow up with the store directly to learn about any special discount days or seasonal sales they might offer

Before You Go

Since Tin Lilly's specific operating hours aren't currently listed, we recommend calling ahead at 631-419-6460 to confirm when they're open and to inquire about their schedule. Many local thrift stores in the Bayport area tend to have varying hours, and some operate on seasonal schedules. Calling ahead ensures you won't make a wasted trip and gives you the opportunity to ask about any special sales or new inventory arrivals that might make your visit even more rewarding.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Tin Lilly:

Find More Thrift Stores in Bayport, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Bayport, NY.