Finders Keepers

Finders Keepers, located at 47 Main St in the heart of Mt Morris, New York, is a community-focused thrift store that brings affordable shopping to Livingston County residents. As part of the ARC GLOW network, this welcoming shop serves a dual purpose: offering bargain hunters an ever-changing selection of secondhand treasures while supporting programs that benefit people with developmental disabilities in the region. The store's compact Main Street location makes it easy to pop in during your weekly errands, and the friendly staff create a warm, no-pressure browsing environment that keeps locals coming back. Whether you're furnishing your first apartment, hunting for unique vintage pieces, or simply love the thrill of discovering unexpected finds, Finders Keepers delivers that authentic thrift store experience that's become harder to find in today's retail landscape.

Store Information

47 Main St, Mt Morris, NY 14510

Phone: +1 585-658-2358

Email: wsofia@arcglow.org

Website: https://arcglow.org/business-services/finders-keepers/

Store Hours

  • Monday: 10AM-4PM
  • Tuesday: 10AM-4PM
  • Wednesday: 10AM-4PM
  • Thursday: 10AM-4PM
  • Friday: 10AM-4PM
  • Saturday: 10AM-2PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

Finders Keepers offers a rotating inventory of quality secondhand goods that reflect the needs and tastes of the Mt Morris community. Shoppers can browse through clothing for all ages and seasons, household items, kitchen essentials, books, small furniture pieces, and decorative accents. The selection changes regularly as donations come in, so you might discover vintage collectibles one week and gently-used children's toys the next. Since all proceeds support ARC GLOW's mission, every purchase makes a difference while keeping usable items out of landfills and in the hands of community members who appreciate them.

The Neighborhood

Mt Morris is a charming village in Livingston County, New York, known for its small-town character and proximity to Letchworth State Park, the 'Grand Canyon of the East.' The Main Street location puts Finders Keepers right in the village's walkable downtown district, surrounded by local businesses and historic architecture. It's an easy stop for residents from nearby Geneseo, Leicester, and Nunda, with Route 408 providing convenient access for shoppers throughout the southern Genesee Valley region.

Parking

Street parking along Main Street in Mt Morris is typically your best option when visiting Finders Keepers, with spaces usually available right in front of or near the store. The village's downtown area is rarely congested, making it easy to find a spot within a short walk. Be mindful of any posted time limits during business hours, though most shoppers find plenty of time to browse comfortably.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit early in the week for the best selection after new donations have been processed and displayed
  • Bring cash if possible, as smaller thrift stores sometimes have limited card processing options
  • Check in regularly since inventory turns over quickly and unique items don't last long
  • Ask staff about donation days or if they're expecting any special items—they often know what's coming
  • Don't hesitate to negotiate on larger furniture pieces, especially if you're buying multiple items

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Finders Keepers:

Find More Thrift Stores in Mt Morris, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Mt Morris, NY.