St Anselm's Thrift Shop" Anselms Attic "

St Anselm's Thrift Shop, affectionately known as "Anselm's Attic," is a cherished community thrift store located at 4 Woodville Rd in Shoreham, New York. Operating as a church-affiliated thrift shop, this cozy treasure trove offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere where every purchase supports the St Anselm's community mission. Unlike large commercial thrift chains, Anselm's Attic provides that authentic small-town shopping experience where volunteers often greet you by name and take pride in curating quality donated items. The shop's intimate setting allows for a more personal browsing experience, where you can actually take your time exploring without feeling overwhelmed. Locals appreciate the shop's commitment to keeping prices affordable while maintaining high standards for the items they accept, making it a favorite destination for budget-conscious shoppers and vintage hunters alike in the North Shore community of Long Island.

Store Information

4 Woodville Rd, Shoreham, NY 11786

Phone: +1 631-744-7730

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: 10AM-2PM
  • Thursday: Closed
  • Friday: Closed
  • Saturday: 10AM-2PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

Anselm's Attic offers a rotating selection of gently used items typical of church-affiliated thrift shops, including household goods, clothing for all ages, books, small furniture pieces, and decorative items. Since the inventory depends entirely on community donations, you'll find an ever-changing array of treasures that reflect the character of Shoreham's generous residents. The shop maintains good quality standards, ensuring that items are clean and functional before they hit the sales floor. You might discover vintage kitchenware, children's toys, linens, seasonal decorations, and the occasional antique piece that makes thrift shopping here a genuine treasure hunt.

The Neighborhood

Shoreham is a quiet, family-oriented hamlet on Long Island's North Shore, known for its residential charm and proximity to the Long Island Sound. Located in Suffolk County, this peaceful community offers easy access to Woodville Road, a residential area that provides a serene shopping environment away from busy commercial strips. The neighborhood's close-knit feel makes St Anselm's Thrift Shop a natural gathering spot for locals who appreciate supporting community organizations while finding great deals.

Parking

Parking at St Anselm's Thrift Shop on Woodville Road is typically straightforward, with on-site parking available at the church property. The residential location means you'll avoid the hassles of crowded shopping center lots. Street parking is also usually available along Woodville Road if needed, and the quiet neighborhood setting makes for easy, stress-free access to the shop entrance.

Shopping Tips

  • Arrive right at 10 AM opening time on Wednesdays or Saturdays for the best selection before items get picked over
  • Bring cash or check, as small church thrift shops often don't have credit card processing capabilities
  • Visit in early fall and spring when people typically donate seasonal items during closet cleanouts
  • Ask the volunteers about donation drop-off times if you're looking for specific items—they often know what's coming in
  • Check back regularly since inventory completely changes based on community donations, and that perfect find might appear any week

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near St Anselm's Thrift Shop" Anselms Attic ":

Find More Thrift Stores in Shoreham, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Shoreham, NY.