Our care and share thrift store

Our Care and Share Thrift Store has become a beloved shopping destination on Main Street in Mexico, New York, offering community members an affordable way to find quality secondhand items while supporting a good cause. Located at 3268 Main St, this welcoming thrift store serves as both a practical resource for budget-conscious shoppers and a gathering place where neighbors connect over shared values of sustainability and community giving. The store's limited but consistent hours create a sense of anticipation among regular visitors who know that each visit might reveal unexpected treasures. What sets Our Care and Share apart is its genuine connection to the Mexico community—this isn't just a place to shop, it's a local institution where every purchase helps support important community programs and where donated items find new life with families who need them most.

Store Information

3268 Main St, Mexico, NY 13114

Phone: +1 315-963-3142

Store Hours

  • Monday: 11AM-3PM
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: 4-6:30PM
  • Thursday: Closed
  • Friday: 11AM-3PM
  • Saturday: Closed
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

Our Care and Share Thrift Store offers a diverse selection of gently used items that change with each donation cycle. Shoppers can typically find clothing for the whole family, household goods, small furniture pieces, books, kitchenware, and decorative items. The inventory reflects the generous spirit of the Mexico community, with quality donations from local families ensuring a rotating selection of practical everyday items. Whether you're furnishing a first apartment, looking for unique vintage finds, or simply stretching your household budget, the ever-changing stock means there's always something new to discover during each visit.

The Neighborhood

Downtown Mexico, New York offers small-town charm with easy access along Main Street, one of Oswego County's most recognizable thoroughfares. The area features a mix of local businesses, community services, and residential neighborhoods where generations of families have put down roots. Our Care and Share Thrift Store sits in the heart of this tight-knit community, making it a convenient stop for locals running errands or visitors exploring the historic downtown district.

Parking

Parking at 3268 Main St in Mexico is typically straightforward, with street parking available directly in front of the store and along nearby sections of Main Street. The downtown location means spaces can fill up during peak business hours, but the store's off-peak operating times usually make finding a convenient spot easier. Be mindful of any posted time limits or parking regulations along Main Street to avoid tickets while you browse.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit on Monday mornings right at 11AM opening for first pick of newly stocked items from weekend donations
  • Bring cash just in case, as smaller community thrift stores sometimes have limited card processing capabilities
  • Check back frequently since the limited operating hours mean inventory turnover happens quickly between visits
  • Don't hesitate to ask volunteers about specific items you're seeking—they often know what's in back or coming soon
  • Consider timing your visit for Wednesday evenings if daytime shopping doesn't fit your schedule, as you'll face less competition from other shoppers

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Our care and share thrift store:

Find More Thrift Stores in Mexico, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Mexico, NY.