The Thrift Shop & Barn @ St. Gerard Majella

The Thrift Shop & Barn @ St. Gerard Majella has been a cherished treasure trove for bargain hunters in Port Jefferson Station, New York for years. Located at 316 Terryville Rd, this community-focused thrift store operates as part of the St. Gerard Majella parish, making every purchase support local church programs and charitable initiatives. The shop offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere where you'll find dedicated volunteers who genuinely care about helping shoppers discover hidden gems at unbeatable prices. What sets The Thrift Shop & Barn apart is its dual-space layout, with both the main shop and barn area filled with constantly rotating inventory. Locals love stopping by regularly because new donations arrive frequently, meaning there's always something different to discover. Whether you're furnishing a first apartment, hunting for vintage finds, or simply enjoy the thrill of thrifting, this Port Jefferson Station staple delivers quality items at prices that can't be beat at traditional retail stores.

Store Information

316 Terryville Rd, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776

Phone: +1 631-473-2900

Email: office@stgmajella.org

Website: http://www.stgmajella.org/parish-life/thrift-shop

Store Hours

  • Monday: 10AM-4PM
  • Tuesday: 10AM-4PM
  • Wednesday: 10AM-4PM
  • Thursday: 10AM-4PM
  • Friday: 10AM-2PM
  • Saturday: Closed
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

The Thrift Shop & Barn @ St. Gerard Majella offers an ever-changing selection of gently used household items, clothing for the whole family, books, decorative pieces, and furniture. Shoppers can browse through racks of men's, women's, and children's apparel in various styles and sizes, along with shoes and accessories. The barn area typically houses larger items including furniture pieces, kitchenware, small appliances, and seasonal decorations. Quality varies from everyday essentials to surprising vintage finds and brand-name items donated by generous community members. Since all proceeds support the parish's charitable mission, prices remain incredibly affordable while inventory quality stays consistently good thanks to careful volunteer curation.

The Neighborhood

Port Jefferson Station is a friendly, residential community in central Suffolk County that offers small-town charm with convenient access to Route 112 and the Long Island Expressway. Located along Terryville Road, The Thrift Shop & Barn sits in an easily accessible area close to local schools, residential neighborhoods, and shopping districts. The community has a strong tradition of supporting local churches and charitable organizations, making this thrift store a natural gathering spot for neighbors. Its location provides easy access for shoppers from surrounding communities including Port Jefferson, Coram, and Mount Sinai.

Parking

Parking at The Thrift Shop & Barn @ St. Gerard Majella is straightforward and convenient, with an on-site parking lot adjacent to the church property on Terryville Road. The lot provides ample space for shoppers, including areas close to both the main shop entrance and barn area for easy loading of larger purchases. Street parking along Terryville Road is also available if the lot is busy during peak afternoon hours.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit early in the week, especially Monday or Tuesday mornings, when newly sorted weekend donations hit the floor with the freshest selection
  • Bring cash for the quickest checkout, though it's worth calling ahead to confirm current payment options
  • Check both the main thrift shop and the barn area—larger furniture pieces and seasonal items are often housed separately in the barn
  • Ask volunteers about upcoming donation drives or special sale days when prices may be reduced even further
  • Consider donating your gently used items when you visit; it supports the parish mission and keeps inventory fresh for everyone

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near The Thrift Shop & Barn @ St. Gerard Majella:

Find More Thrift Stores in Port Jefferson Station, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Port Jefferson Station, NY.