Matthew’s Closet

Matthew's Closet is a treasured community thrift store located in the heart of Rochester, New York. Founded with a mission to serve those in need, this welcoming shop at 316 Bay St offers quality secondhand clothing and household items at accessible prices. What sets Matthew's Closet apart is their commitment to dignity—creating a shopping environment where everyone feels respected regardless of their financial situation. The store operates as part of the Catholic Family Center's initiatives, channeling proceeds back into community support services. Rochester residents frequent Matthew's Closet not just for the affordable finds, but for the warm atmosphere and knowledge that their purchases help sustain important social services in their community.

Store Information

316 Bay St, Rochester, NY 14605

Phone: +1 585-232-5160

Website: https://www.matthewscloset.org/

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: 10AM-4PM
  • Wednesday: 10AM-4PM
  • Thursday: 10AM-4PM
  • Friday: Closed
  • Saturday: 10AM-3PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

Matthew's Closet specializes in quality secondhand clothing for men, women, and children of all ages and sizes. Their carefully selected inventory includes seasonal apparel, professional attire, casual wear, and outerwear to suit Rochester's varied climate. Beyond clothing, shoppers can discover household essentials, small furniture pieces, and gently used shoes and accessories. The store takes pride in ensuring all items meet quality standards before hitting the sales floor, offering dignified shopping for those on tight budgets. Many items arrive with original tags still attached, providing exceptional value for budget-conscious Rochester residents.

The Neighborhood

Located on Bay Street in Northeast Rochester, Matthew's Closet sits in a diverse, historically rich neighborhood. The area is conveniently positioned near St. Paul Street and within walking distance of the Upper Falls Boulevard area. This accessible location serves residents from throughout Rochester, with proximity to public transportation routes. The surrounding neighborhood has a strong community spirit, with several churches, community centers, and local businesses contributing to its character.

Parking

Matthew's Closet offers convenient parking options for Rochester shoppers. The store has a modest dedicated lot with free parking directly adjacent to the building on Bay Street. Additional free street parking is typically available along Bay Street itself. During busier Saturday hours, you might need to park a short distance away, but the neighborhood generally offers sufficient parking within a block or two of the store.

Shopping Tips

  • Sign up for Matthew's Closet email updates to learn about special sales and discount days that aren't advertised elsewhere.
  • Visit midweek for the most peaceful shopping experience with better staff availability for assistance.
  • Come prepared with measurements if shopping for furniture or larger household items, as space is limited and returns aren't typically accepted.
  • Donations are processed regularly, so establish a routine visiting schedule to catch new inventory before other Rochester bargain-hunters.
  • Ask staff about their volunteer opportunities—many loyal shoppers also donate time to support this community-focused Rochester thrift store.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Matthew’s Closet:

Find More Thrift Stores in Rochester, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Rochester, NY.