Wow! That's Unusual!

Nestled in the heart of Suffern, New York, Wow! That's Unusual! lives up to its intriguing name by offering a truly exceptional thrifting experience. This hidden gem at 22 Lafayette Ave specializes in the quirky, the vintage, and the wonderfully unexpected. Unlike conventional thrift stores, Wow! That's Unusual! curates a collection that celebrates individuality and eccentricity, making every shopping trip a treasure hunt for the unconventional shopper. What sets Wow! That's Unusual! apart is their thoughtfully organized layout and commitment to quality even among the most eccentric items. Locals in Suffern frequently visit to discover conversation pieces, retro collectibles, and one-of-a-kind gifts that simply can't be found elsewhere. The friendly staff adds to the charm, often sharing stories behind particularly unusual finds and creating an atmosphere that makes browsing as enjoyable as finding that perfect unusual treasure.

Store Information

22 Lafayette Ave #5406, Suffern, NY 10901

Phone: +1 845-918-1352

Website: http://www.wowthatsunusual.com/

Store Hours

  • Monday: 10AM-8PM
  • Tuesday: 10AM-8PM
  • Wednesday: 10AM-8PM
  • Thursday: 10AM-8PM
  • Friday: 12-10PM
  • Saturday: 12-10PM
  • Sunday: 10AM-5PM

What They Sell

Wow! That's Unusual! specializes in the extraordinary and unexpected, featuring an ever-changing inventory of vintage oddities, retro collectibles, and conversation pieces that defy conventional categorization. Shoppers can expect to find everything from mid-century knick-knacks and vintage clothing with character to bizarre artwork, unusual home décor, and quirky accessories that make perfect gifts for those who appreciate the distinctive. The store particularly excels in curating items with backstories – pieces that aren't merely old but genuinely interesting and conversation-worthy.

The Neighborhood

Suffern, New York offers a charming small-town atmosphere with big personality, making it the perfect home for Wow! That's Unusual!. Located on Lafayette Avenue near the historic Lafayette Theatre and just a short walk from the Suffern train station, the store sits in a vibrant area with local eateries and boutiques. This Rockland County gem provides visitors with easy access from nearby communities and features the scenic backdrop of the Ramapo Mountains, adding to the quaint shopping experience.

Parking

Visitors to Wow! That's Unusual! can typically find street parking along Lafayette Avenue, with the most convenient spots often available in the morning hours. The nearby municipal lot offers additional options just a short walk away. During peak weekend shopping hours, you might need to circle the block, but the hunt for parking is well worth the unique treasures awaiting inside the store.

Shopping Tips

  • Sign up for their email list at the register or through their website (wowthatsunusual.com) to get first notifications when particularly unusual items arrive.
  • Visit on Wednesdays when new inventory is typically put out on the floor – the staff calls this 'Weird Wednesday' for good reason!
  • Don't hesitate to ask about items in the back room; some of the most unusual finds aren't even on display yet.
  • Bring measurements of spaces in your home if you're looking for odd furniture or décor pieces.
  • Check their social media for flash sales, which often happen when they need to make room for new unusual arrivals.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Wow! That's Unusual!:

Find More Thrift Stores in Suffern, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Suffern, NY.