Second Time Around

Second Time Around has become a beloved thrift shopping destination on Lake Ave in Hilton, New York, offering local bargain hunters a chance to discover quality secondhand treasures. This community-focused shop brings the thrill of the hunt to Rochester's northern suburbs, where shoppers can browse thoughtfully curated selections without the overwhelming clutter that sometimes plagues larger thrift operations. Located at 155 Lake Ave, Second Time Around serves both Hilton residents and visitors from neighboring Greece and Parma who appreciate the value and sustainability of secondhand shopping. Whether you're furnishing a first apartment, searching for unique vintage finds, or simply enjoy the excitement of discovering unexpected gems, this Hilton thrift store provides a welcoming environment where every visit brings new possibilities and the satisfaction of finding quality items at prices that won't break the bank.

Store Information

155 Lake Ave, Hilton, NY 14468

Phone: +1 585-392-9179

Store Hours

Typical thrift store hours — please call ahead to confirm:

  • Monday–Saturday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
  • Sunday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM

What They Sell

Second Time Around offers a diverse selection of secondhand merchandise that appeals to budget-conscious shoppers and treasure hunters alike. Customers can typically find an ever-changing inventory at thrift stores like this, including gently used clothing for the whole family, household goods, small furniture pieces, books, decorative items, and seasonal merchandise. The quality and selection vary with donations, which means regular visitors often have the best luck discovering those special finds. From everyday essentials to unique vintage pieces, the inventory at this Hilton location reflects the generous donations from the local community, ensuring there's always something new to discover on each visit.

The Neighborhood

Hilton is a charming lakeside village in Monroe County, New York, situated just north of Rochester along the scenic Lake Ontario State Parkway. The Lake Ave corridor provides easy access for shoppers throughout the greater Rochester area, with Second Time Around positioned conveniently for both village residents and those traveling from nearby Brockport or Spencerport. This friendly community maintains a small-town atmosphere while offering the shopping conveniences that locals appreciate, making it an ideal spot for a leisurely thrift store visit.

Parking

Shopping at Second Time Around on Lake Ave typically offers convenient parking options common to Hilton's village commercial areas. Most businesses along this corridor provide dedicated parking lots or ample street parking, making it easy to stop in even during busy shopping hours. The laid-back nature of Hilton means you'll rarely struggle to find a spot close to the entrance, perfect for loading larger finds into your vehicle.

Shopping Tips

  • Call ahead at +1 585-392-9179 to confirm current hours and ask about their best days for new inventory arrivals
  • Visit frequently since thrift store inventory changes constantly based on community donations—what's available one week may be completely different the next
  • Bring cash just in case, as some smaller thrift operations in the area may have limited card payment options
  • Take your time browsing and check items carefully for condition, since all sales at thrift stores are typically final
  • Ask staff if they offer regular discount days or senior specials to maximize your savings on future visits

Before You Go

While specific operating hours for Second Time Around aren't currently listed, we recommend calling ahead at +1 585-392-9179 to confirm when they're open and to ask about their best shopping times. Many thrift stores in the Hilton area receive fresh inventory mid-week and early in the week, so visiting on Tuesday through Thursday mornings often means first access to newly stocked shelves. Calling ahead also gives you the opportunity to ask about any upcoming sales or special discount days that could maximize your savings.

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Second Time Around:

Find More Thrift Stores in Hilton, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Hilton, NY.