Once Again Shoppe

Once Again Shoppe has become a beloved fixture in Penn Yan, New York, offering treasure hunters and bargain seekers a carefully curated selection of secondhand goods. Located at 100 E Elm St in the heart of Penn Yan, this welcoming thrift store provides locals and visitors alike with an opportunity to discover quality pre-loved items while supporting their community. The shop's friendly atmosphere and well-organized displays make browsing a pleasure rather than a chore. Whether you're furnishing your first apartment, looking for unique vintage pieces, or simply enjoy the thrill of finding unexpected treasures, Once Again Shoppe delivers that authentic thrift store experience that keeps customers coming back. The store has earned a reputation among Penn Yan residents as a go-to destination for sustainable shopping and budget-friendly finds, proving that one person's "once" can definitely become another person's favorite "again."

Store Information

100 E Elm St, Penn Yan, NY 14527

Phone: +1 315-536-3620

Website: https://www.facebook.com/TheOnceAgainShoppe

Store Hours

  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: 10AM-4PM
  • Thursday: 10AM-4PM
  • Friday: 10AM-4PM
  • Saturday: 10AM-2PM
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

Once Again Shoppe offers a rotating inventory of quality secondhand items that reflect the needs and tastes of the Penn Yan community. Shoppers can typically find a diverse mix of household goods, clothing for all ages, books, décor items, and seasonal merchandise. Like many community-focused thrift stores, the selection changes regularly based on donations and consignments, meaning each visit offers something new to discover. The store maintains reasonable quality standards while keeping prices accessible, making it popular with everyone from college students and young families to vintage enthusiasts and collectors looking for that perfect piece.

The Neighborhood

Penn Yan sits at the northern tip of Keuka Lake in New York's stunning Finger Lakes region, offering small-town charm with beautiful lakeside scenery. The downtown area along Elm Street features historic architecture, local businesses, and a strong sense of community. Once Again Shoppe's location puts shoppers within easy walking distance of Penn Yan's Main Street shops, restaurants, and the Yates County Courthouse, making it convenient to combine thrift shopping with other errands or a leisurely afternoon exploring this picturesque village.

Parking

Parking at Once Again Shoppe on E Elm Street is typically straightforward, with on-street parking available along the downtown Penn Yan blocks. The area generally offers free street parking with reasonable time limits during business hours. Downtown Penn Yan is compact and walkable, so you'll usually find a spot within a short stroll of the store, especially during weekday shopping hours.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit early in the week (Wednesday or Thursday mornings) when Once Again Shoppe restocks and displays new donations from the weekend
  • Bring cash just in case, as some smaller thrift stores in the Finger Lakes region may have limited card payment options
  • Check their Facebook page before visiting for any special sales, holiday hours, or announcements about unique inventory
  • Take your time browsing—thrift shopping rewards patience, and the best finds are often tucked away waiting to be discovered
  • Ask staff about items you're specifically seeking; they often know the inventory well and can point you in the right direction

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Once Again Shoppe:

Find More Thrift Stores in Penn Yan, NY

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Penn Yan, NY.