Old & New Thrift Shop

Old & New Thrift Shop has been a beloved treasure hunting destination in Manahawkin, New Jersey for bargain seekers and eco-conscious shoppers alike. Located conveniently on East Bay Avenue, this welcoming thrift store offers a carefully curated selection of pre-loved items that change regularly, making each visit a fresh adventure. The shop's charm lies in its commitment to the community and its mission to keep quality goods in circulation while offering unbeatable prices. Shoppers at Old & New Thrift Shop appreciate the well-organized layout and friendly atmosphere that makes browsing a pleasure rather than a chore. Unlike larger impersonal thrift chains, this Manahawkin gem maintains that small-town feel where staff recognize regular faces and take pride in helping customers find exactly what they need. Whether you're furnishing a Shore house, hunting for vintage finds, or simply enjoying the thrill of discovering hidden gems, this Bay Avenue location has become a go-to stop for locals and visitors exploring the Long Beach Island area.

Store Information

440 E Bay Ave, Manahawkin, NJ 08050

Phone: +1 609-597-3470

Email: socholdnewshop@gmail.com

Website: http://oldnewthriftshop.com/

3.7★ average across 135 reviews on Google

Store Hours

  • Monday: 9:30AM-2:30PM
  • Tuesday: 9:30AM-2:30PM
  • Wednesday: 9:30AM-2:30PM
  • Thursday: 9:30AM-2:30PM
  • Friday: 9:30AM-2:30PM
  • Saturday: Closed
  • Sunday: Closed

What They Sell

Old & New Thrift Shop offers a rotating inventory of gently used items that reflects the diverse needs of the Shore community. Shoppers can discover quality household goods, furniture pieces perfect for beach homes, decorative items, kitchenware, and seasonal merchandise. The selection changes frequently as new donations arrive, so regular visitors often find completely different treasures from week to week. The shop maintains standards for cleanliness and quality, ensuring that items on the floor are in good, usable condition and priced fairly for the value-conscious shopper.

The Neighborhood

Manahawkin serves as the gateway to Long Beach Island and is the commercial hub of Stafford Township, New Jersey. This vibrant community sits along Route 72, making Old & New Thrift Shop easily accessible for both year-round residents and seasonal Shore visitors. The Bay Avenue location places shoppers near local restaurants, banks, and essential services, perfect for combining thrift shopping with other errands in this bustling Ocean County town.

Parking

Parking at Old & New Thrift Shop on East Bay Avenue is typically straightforward, with options available directly near the storefront. The Manahawkin location offers convenient access with on-site parking spaces that make loading larger finds into your vehicle hassle-free. Street parking may also be available along Bay Avenue during business hours, giving shoppers flexibility when the main lot is busy.

Shopping Tips

  • Visit early in the week, especially Monday mornings, when fresh inventory from weekend donations is typically processed and put on the floor
  • Bring cash when possible, as smaller thrift shops sometimes offer better deals or have limited card processing capabilities
  • Check back frequently since the 9:30 AM to 2:30 PM schedule means quick turnover of popular items
  • Ask staff about donation days or when new merchandise arrives to time your visits strategically
  • Bring measurements if you're furniture shopping, as the compact weekday hours don't always allow time for return trips to measure spaces at home

Nearby Thrift Stores

Other thrift, vintage, and second-hand stores near Old & New Thrift Shop:

Find More Thrift Stores in Manahawkin, NJ

Discover more second-hand shops and vintage stores near Manahawkin, NJ.