Thrift Stores in Bay Shore, New York
Listing data updated November 19, 2025.
Bay Shore, New York has 2 thrift stores listed in our directory, from charity shops and consignment stores to vintage boutiques.
Every listing below includes the address and phone number where available, so you can plan a thrift route through Bay Shore before you go. Check individual store pages for hours, directions, nearby shops, and live Loot Map deals.
2 Thrift Stores in Bay Shore
- Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop - 1601 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 - +1 631-666-6207
- St Peter's By the Sea Thrift Shop - 500 S Country Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706 - +1 631-665-0051
Thrift Shopping in Bay Shore: Common Questions
How many thrift stores are in Bay Shore?
There are 2 thrift stores listed in Bay Shore, New York, including charity shops, consignment stores, and vintage boutiques.
What is the best day to go thrifting in Bay Shore?
Most thrift stores restock early in the week after weekend donations, so Monday through Wednesday mornings usually have the freshest selection. Call ahead to confirm hours before you go.
Thrifting Near Bay Shore: More New York Cities
- Thrift Stores in Brooklyn (79)
- Thrift Stores in New York (78)
- Thrift Stores in Buffalo (26)
- Thrift Stores in Rochester (25)
- Thrift Stores in Bronx (24)
- Thrift Stores in Kingston (16)
- Thrift Stores in Staten Island (15)
- Thrift Stores in Albany (11)
- Thrift Stores in Syracuse (11)
- Thrift Stores in Poughkeepsie (9)