Thrift Stores Open on Sunday in Indianapolis: Your Complete Weekend Guide
By My Local Thrift Store ·
Why Sunday Is the Best Day to Go Thrifting in Indianapolis
There's something almost ritualistic about a Sunday thrift run. The week is winding down, you've got nowhere urgent to be, and the racks are freshly restocked from the weekend's donations. Indianapolis has a thriving secondhand scene — from neighborhood resale boutiques to massive Goodwill outlets — and Sunday is honestly one of the best days to take it all in. Whether you're hunting for vintage furniture, designer clothes at a fraction of the price, or just browsing with a cup of coffee in hand, Indy's thrift stores deliver.
Indianapolis has quietly become one of the Midwest's best cities for thrifting. The city's mix of longtime charity-run shops, curated resale boutiques, and massive donation-based chains means there's something for every kind of secondhand shopper. And because many stores receive fresh inventory throughout the week, Sunday often means you're walking into a floor that's been refreshed since Friday — which is exactly the kind of edge experienced thrifters look for.
To help you make the most of your Sunday, we've pulled together a verified list of thrift stores open on Sunday in Indianapolis, Indiana. Each one brings something different to the table, so read on to find your next favorite spot — and maybe a few hidden gems along the way.
Thrift Stores Open on Sunday in Indianapolis
Habitat for Humanity ReStore — 1011 E 22nd St
If you've never been to a Habitat for Humanity ReStore, you're in for a treat — especially if home improvement is your thing. This Indianapolis location at 1011 E 22nd St (📞 317-777-6098) is stocked with donated and surplus building materials, appliances, furniture, and home décor, all sold at steep discounts. Every purchase directly supports Habitat for Humanity's mission to build affordable housing in the community, so you're doing good while scoring deals. On Sundays, this is a go-to for DIYers, flippers, and anyone furnishing a new space on a budget. Arrive early — large items like cabinets, doors, and lighting fixtures tend to move fast.
Thrifty Threads — 1501 W 86th St
Clothing lovers, this one's for you. Thrifty Threads at 1501 W 86th St (📞 317-802-9612) is a neighborhood staple known for a well-organized selection of secondhand clothing for men, women, and kids. The staff here puts real effort into curation, which means you spend less time digging through clutter and more time actually finding things you love. Sunday shoppers tend to find the store in great shape after the weekend rush gets going — inventory turns over quickly, so visiting multiple Sundays in a row often yields completely different finds. If you're building a capsule wardrobe on a thrift budget, this is a solid starting point.
Mission 27 Resale — Indianapolis, IN
Mission 27 Resale is more than just a thrift store — it's a shop with a purpose. Tied to nonprofit work in the Indianapolis community, shopping here means your dollars are going somewhere meaningful beyond the register. The store carries a rotating mix of clothing, household goods, and accessories, and the vibe is welcoming and community-oriented. If you're someone who wants their spending to have an impact, Mission 27 is worth seeking out on your next Sunday thrift run. Keep an eye on their social channels for special sale days and donation drives that can make visits even more rewarding.
Vogue Exchange — Indianapolis, IN
Vogue Exchange is Indianapolis's answer to the curated resale boutique. Unlike your typical donation-based thrift store, Vogue Exchange focuses on quality over quantity — expect carefully selected clothing and accessories that lean toward style-forward and fashion-conscious shoppers. This is the kind of place where you might find a barely-worn designer piece sitting next to a perfectly vintage blazer. If you're the type of thrifter who knows exactly what they're looking for and appreciates a well-edited rack, Vogue Exchange is a must-visit. Sunday afternoons tend to be a great time to browse without the weekday rush.
DAV Thrift Store — 45 S Ridgeview Dr
The DAV (Disabled American Veterans) Thrift Store at 45 S Ridgeview Dr (📞 317-357-0393) is one of those stores that rewards patient shoppers. Sales from this location support programs and services for disabled American veterans, making every purchase a small act of gratitude. The inventory here covers clothing, shoes, housewares, books, and more — and because it's donation-driven, what you find can vary wildly from week to week. That's part of the fun. Sunday visits are particularly good for furniture and larger household items that get dropped off over the weekend. Come with an open mind and you'll rarely leave empty-handed.
Goodwill Store — 5720 Sunnyside Rd
Goodwill needs no introduction, but the Sunnyside Road location (📞 317-524-4313) is worth highlighting on its own. This store is well-stocked across virtually every category — clothing, electronics, books, kitchenware, toys, and furniture — and benefits from the high volume of donations that Goodwill's name recognition attracts. Sunday is a great day to visit because many locations run color-tag discount rotations that can slash prices even further. Whether you're a seasoned thrifter or just getting started, this Goodwill is a reliable, accessible option that rarely disappoints.
Goodwill Store — 9510 Corporation Dr
The Corporation Drive Goodwill location (📞 317-524-4313) serves the northeast Indianapolis area and is another strong option for Sunday thrifting. Like its Sunnyside Road counterpart, this store carries a wide range of goods across all departments, and the turnover rate is high enough that frequent visitors are almost always rewarded with new finds. If you're making a day of it, pairing both Goodwill locations in one Sunday outing is a smart strategy — they're different enough in inventory that you won't feel like you're repeating yourself.
Goodwill of Central Indiana — Indianapolis, IN
Goodwill of Central Indiana is the regional powerhouse behind multiple store locations across the Indianapolis metro area. As one of the largest Goodwill affiliates in the country, Goodwill of Central Indiana operates with a strong local mission: providing job training, employment placement, and community support programs funded by thrift store sales. When you shop at any Goodwill of Central Indiana location on a Sunday, you're contributing to a network that helps thousands of people in the region each year. Check their website for a full list of locations and Sunday hours near you.
Tips for Thrifting in Indianapolis on Sundays
- Go early for the best selection. Sunday mornings — right when stores open — tend to offer the freshest inventory before the afternoon crowd picks through the racks. Set your alarm and treat it like a treasure hunt.
- Check for weekly sale days. Many Indianapolis thrift stores run rotating color-tag or category discounts on specific days of the week. Call ahead or check social media to find out if Sunday happens to be a discount day at your target store.
- Bring measurements for furniture shopping. If you're eyeing bigger items at places like Habitat for Humanity ReStore or Goodwill, know your room dimensions before you go. Great furniture finds disappear fast, and you don't want to pass on something perfect because you weren't sure if it would fit.
- Shop with a flexible mindset. The best thrift finds are rarely the ones you planned for. Give yourself time to browse beyond your usual categories — the kitchen section might have a vintage lamp, or the book aisle might hide a collectible you didn't know you needed.
- Support stores that give back. Indianapolis has several thrift stores tied directly to charitable missions — DAV, Habitat for Humanity, Mission 27, and Goodwill all funnel proceeds into community programs. Knowing where your money goes makes the shopping experience that much more satisfying.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are thrift stores in Indianapolis open on Sundays?
Yes, many thrift stores in Indianapolis are open on Sundays. Major chains like Goodwill typically operate seven days a week, while specialty and nonprofit stores like DAV Thrift Store and Habitat for Humanity ReStore also maintain Sunday hours. It's always a good idea to call ahead or check the store's website to confirm current Sunday hours before making the trip.
What is the best thrift store in Indianapolis for clothing?
It depends on what you're looking for. Thrifty Threads at 1501 W 86th St is a great all-around option for organized, affordable secondhand clothing. If you prefer a more curated, boutique-style experience, Vogue Exchange in Indianapolis focuses on quality and style-forward pieces. Goodwill locations across the city also carry a large volume of clothing across all sizes and styles.
What thrift stores in Indianapolis support local charities?
Several Indianapolis thrift stores are directly tied to charitable missions. Habitat for Humanity ReStore supports affordable housing construction. The DAV Thrift Store benefits disabled American veterans. Mission 27 Resale supports local nonprofit work. Goodwill of Central Indiana funds job training and employment programs throughout the region. Shopping at any of these stores means your purchase goes beyond just a great deal.
Find Even More Thrift Stores in Indianapolis
Indianapolis has a rich and growing thrift scene, and the stores listed here are just the beginning. If you own or manage a secondhand shop in the area, you can claim your store on mylocalthriftstore.com to get in front of thousands of thrift shoppers searching for stores just like yours. Our directory features 27,000+ verified thrift stores across the United States, making it the largest resource of its kind for secondhand shoppers everywhere.
For a deeper dive into Indianapolis's thrift scene — including store hours, directions, and shopper reviews — visit our Indianapolis thrift store guide for the full picture.
Ready to start hunting? Find more thrift stores near you at mylocalthriftstore.com — your go-to directory for secondhand shopping across the US.